korrents
Nate Silver

What Nate Silver thinks about politics

@nate-silver · 126 positions · 1 change of mind · On ppll ↗

Forecaster, founder of FiveThirtyEight, author of The Signal and the Noise and On the Edge. Writes Silver Bulletin, where the predictions come with numbers and the numbers are later checked against what happened.

Nate Silver did not write this page.

We collected these quotes from things they published elsewhere, and every quote links to where it was said. They have no account here and have not endorsed this site. Quotes are word for word; the short line under each one is our own restatement, not their wording. Their own site. Is this you? Claim it or ask us to remove it. Or tell us what is wrong here.

54 dated positions, 2015 to 2026, in their own words. Our reading of what Nate Silver has said — not written or endorsed by them.

  1. Even the red state Democrats who won this year spoke with plenty of fire and conviction about high prices, about corruption, and against billionaires like Elon Musk. Those are likely to be winning themes in the presidential nomination as well as being advantages for Democrats in November 2028.

    ↗Fighters vs. uniters and the big blue futurenatesilver.net

  2. religion

    Plus, the Democratic Party has a lot of racial, class, age, religious and gender differences to bridge.

    ↗Fighters vs. uniters and the big blue futurenatesilver.net

  3. 3 days earlier
  4. If you’re the VP to an unpopular president, the rest of your career usually doesn’t go well.

    ↗JD Vance and the VP cursenatesilver.net

  5. The modern level of high partisan loyalty makes it harder for vice presidents to distance themselves from their boss’s policies, however.

    ↗JD Vance and the VP cursenatesilver.net

  6. 3 days earlier
  7. Democrats will probably hold the Senate even if they lose the presidential race in two years.

    ↗The most valuable nomination of all time?natesilver.net

  8. Nevertheless, a trifecta is likely if not certain conditional upon a Democrat winning the presidency.

    ↗The most valuable nomination of all time?natesilver.net

  9. 3 days earlier
  10. Although I have to say that Trump’s decision to replace Susie Wiles with Stephen Miller as his chief of staff isn’t exactly rational behavior given the scope of the Republican defeat.

    ↗An extremely unofficial first look at the 2028 Senate mapnatesilver.net

  11. 3 days earlier
  12. State-by-state polling errors are correlated in midterms but not as much as in presidential years.

    ↗How to judge an election modelnatesilver.net

  13. Gubernatorial races are less partisan than Congressional ones and produce more crossover voting.

    ↗How to judge an election modelnatesilver.net

  14. They are reasonably clear favorites to flip the Senate, and very likely to flip the House.

    ↗It's Judgment Day for Trump (and for pollsters)natesilver.net

  15. This election has felt more like a typical wave, with Democrats’ advantage building over the course of the cycle.

    ↗It's Judgment Day for Trump (and for pollsters)natesilver.net

  16. And the one superpower he has — turning out low-propensity voters in presidential years, the sorts of voters who apparently are often missed by pollsters — has never really worked when Trump himself wasn’t on the ballot.

    ↗It's Judgment Day for Trump (and for pollsters)natesilver.net

  17. 1 day earlier
  18. Polls show that Democrats will win the Senate, perhaps soundly.

    ↗The NYT/Siena polls show a blue tsunaminatesilver.net

  19. 1 day earlier
  20. So there’s at least some evidence that voters in Michigan are sensitive to Democratic unity, or the lack thereof.

    ↗Could Haley Stevens cost Democrats the Senate?natesilver.net

  21. 1 day earlier
  22. Vermont, meanwhile, is one of the most difficult races to forecast on the map.

    ↗SBSQ #32: SuperMegaJumboDeluxe Editionnatesilver.net

  23. Republicans winning the House would be weird: a 95th+ percentile outcome for the party, not an 80th percentile one.

    ↗SBSQ #32: SuperMegaJumboDeluxe Editionnatesilver.net

  24. 1 day earlier
  25. This backs up my hypothesis, which is embedded into FLIPR, that pollsters are acutely aware of past polling errors and trying to correct for them — at the risk of either under-correcting or overcorrecting — and therefore the direction of polling error is hard to predict.

    ↗The cognitive dissonance electionnatesilver.net

  26. 3 days earlier
  27. If the election goes roughly as the polls say it will go, then in some ways it would mark the end of The Trump era, I think.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 1st of 27 in this recording

  28. It's not quite clear to me how big an issue AI is in this election. I think maybe more than people assume, but it could be the biggest issue of 2028.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 2nd of 27 in this recording

  29. But I would say that probably the candidate intangibles, they might move things by 5 points at most

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 4th of 27 in this recording

  30. I'm one of those people who says that other things held equal, that a moderate candidate will do better than a progressive, at least in a purple state like Michigan, right?

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 5th of 27 in this recording

  31. But if you have enough wind at your back, then you can overcome some of those problems.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 6th of 27 in this recording

  32. One reason why Trump beat his polls in '24 was overperformance among young men. The one group you do not want to rely on to turn out in a midterm is usually young men.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 7th of 27 in this recording

  33. But I think people are— there's an anti-incumbent mood. People, I think, are making this implicit calculation about who has power over my life.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 9th of 27 in this recording

  34. data centersenergy

    And in the Midwest in general, you have a lot of data centers, right? Because you want some space, but you don't want to be too far off the grid and too rural. And so, and so that could be a hidden factor too.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 10th of 27 in this recording

  35. But I think Democratic voters have exercised A fair amount of kind of rational discretion, right?

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 17th of 27 in this recording

  36. I think it's 75% migration and 25% kind of a death spiral for the Democratic Party that might be self-reinforcing.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 19th of 27 in this recording

  37. If you want to model it statistically, then it's quite correlated with gas prices, frankly.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 21st of 27 in this recording

  38. When voters felt like the economy was good and objectively it was pretty good in the first 3 years of Trump, that just kind of serves as like a halo

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 22nd of 27 in this recording

  39. I think money is generally overrated in politics. I qualify that by saying for any high-profile race, so Senate, governor, certainly president, where you encounter diminishing returns.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 25th of 27 in this recording

  40. I worry more about the state polls being wrong. than the national race being, being miscalibrated.

    ↗Nate Silver On What the Polls Say — And What His Gut’s Telling Him | The Ezra Klein Showyoutube.com 27th of 27 in this recording

  41. 2 days earlier
  42. It would take a polling error of epic proportions — bigger than in 2016 — for Democrats to fail to pick up the chamber.

    ↗Let’s talk shop about every Senate racenatesilver.net

  43. 2 days earlier
  44. One consistent story this cycle is that Democratic Senate candidates are doing surprisingly well in traditionally red states such as Texas, but in bluer states — most obviously Michigan and Minnesota — their polling has been less than stellar. Don’t bet on that changing dramatically in the final days leading up to the election.

    ↗Do these Senate-governor splits make sense?natesilver.net

  45. Based on FLIPR’s current projections, we expect statewide ticket-splitting to decrease even further, with a median gap of just six points in 2026.

    ↗Do these Senate-governor splits make sense?natesilver.net

  46. Politics is increasingly nationalized, so even though it’s easier for gubernatorial candidates to buck a state’s partisan trends than it is for their Senate counterparts, it’s getting more difficult to be a blue-state Republican or red-state Democrat.

    ↗Do these Senate-governor splits make sense?natesilver.net

  47. 3 days earlier
  48. That doesn’t mean they’ve solved it, because willingness to answer a poll is correlated with voting Democratic, and that’s inherently tricky.

    ↗My pet peeve about the polling error debatenatesilver.net

  49. 7 days earlier
  50. It would take a massive October surprise or a bigger-than-2016 polling error to save the Republican majority there, despite Republicans’ aggressive redistricting.

    ↗Will Republican gerrymanders become dummymanders?natesilver.net

  51. 4 days earlier
  52. There remains a very real chance — about 1 in 4 — that Republicans keep the Senate despite Democrats’ seeming momentum.

    ↗Could Minnesota spoil the blue wave?natesilver.net

  53. Perpetually increasing polarization means that: 1) fewer states are competitive; 2) there’s less and less ticket-splitting, so races for Congress are more predictable based on presidential voting and 3) “candidate effects,” including incumbency, are weaker, so there’s less opportunity for a candidate with strong personal qualities to overcome the partisan tide.

    ↗Could Minnesota spoil the blue wave?natesilver.net

  54. 6 days earlier
  55. Systematic polling errors are common. Polls might be biased against Republicans again. Or against Democrats.

    ↗What if the polls are wrong again?natesilver.net

  56. In the 9 midterms or presidential years I’ve covered since FiveThirtyEight launched in 2008, polls have had a systematic bias against Democrats once, in 2012, a systematic bias against Republicans four times (the three Trump presidential elections + 2014), and were basically unbiased in the other four elections, including in the past two midterms.

    ↗What if the polls are wrong again?natesilver.net

  57. 2 days earlier
  58. Democrats’ voter-targeting efforts are plausibly more efficient and effective than the Republican ones under Trump.

    ↗Why did Ohio stop being a swing state?natesilver.net

  59. 9 days earlier
  60. inflation

    Inflation in fuel prices is much higher in diesel-heavy farm states — and may explain some surprisingly competitive Senate races.

    ↗Diesel prices could crush Republicans in the heartlandnatesilver.net

  61. 2 days earlier
  62. AI alignment

    Conversely, expert ratings imply a much different political environment. The Cook Political Report, for example, counts seven races as “toss-ups,” including states like New Hampshire where models and prediction markets imply that Democrats are heavy favorites. This cautious view is misaligned with the long history of strong opposition performance in midterm elections, especially when the incumbent president is as unpopular as Trump.

    ↗Expert ratings are ignoring signs of a blue wavenatesilver.net

  63. 3 days earlier
  64. So I don’t expect this pro-AI coalition to be very durable. The AI denialists and the Trump fans hate one another.

    ↗A supermajority wants to slow AI downnatesilver.net

  65. 2 weeks earlier
  66. midterm races in the modern era tend not to change all that much between Labor Day and Election Day.

    ↗Beware big swings in midterm forecastsnatesilver.net

  67. A new poll in Michigan or Maine or South Carolina or Alaska pretty much affects that state and that state only.

    ↗Beware big swings in midterm forecastsnatesilver.net

  68. 13 months earlier
  69. And I'd say if it's 2%, then that's still alarmingly high, but it's probably 2% and not 6% or 7%.

    ↗Nate Silver on Life’s Mixed Strategiesyoutube.com 13th of 30 in this recording

  70. I do think there's a chance that Democrats will overestimate how tolerant the rest of the country is for progressive governance.

    ↗Nate Silver on Life’s Mixed Strategiesyoutube.com 14th of 30 in this recording

  71. So I regard Democrats as like a 55-45 favorite for 2028, pricing in some chance he'll nominate what I would think of as a suboptimal from an electoral standpoint candidate.

    ↗Nate Silver on Life’s Mixed Strategiesyoutube.com 15th of 30 in this recording

  72. But yeah, I think the idea of an external savior who's a centrist is becoming a bit less likely than I would have thought a year ago.

    ↗Nate Silver on Life’s Mixed Strategiesyoutube.com 17th of 30 in this recording

  73. Look, I mostly believe in kind of like thermostatic effects in politics where people run in the opposite direction of the kind of status quo more and more.

    ↗Nate Silver on Life’s Mixed Strategiesyoutube.com 28th of 30 in this recording

  74. 9 years earlier
  75. Basically, my view is that putting Trump’s chances at 2 percent or 5 percent was too low, but having him at (for instance) 10 percent or 15 percent, where we might have wound up if we’d developed a model or thought about the problem more rigorously, would have been entirely appropriate.

    We didn’t just get unlucky: We made a big mistake, along with a couple of marginal ones.

    ↗How I Acted Like A Pundit And Screwed Up On Donald Trumpweb.archive.org

  76. 9 months earlier
  77. If you want absurd specificity, I recently estimated Trump’s chance of becoming the GOP nominee at 2 percent.

    ↗Donald Trump’s Six Stages Of Doomweb.archive.org