Tap a claim on the ring to put it at the centre.
← It is very rare for scientists who disagree with each other to talk to each other before a critique.
17 connected korrents · 15 moments from 13 Dec 2022 to 19 Nov 2026.
Everything filed under peer review
peer review
Everything filed under AI and science
AI and science
Everything filed under design
design
Everything filed under physics
physics
Everything filed under humility
humility
Everything filed under chat interfaces
chat interfaces
Everything filed under AI agents
AI agents
Everything filed under LLMs
LLMs
Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject
Read this korrent: It is very rare for scientists who disagree with each other to talk to each other before a critique.
It is very rare for scientists who disagree with each other to talk to each other before a critique.
Last stated 4 years ago
17 Mar 2023
LB
Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-03-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: In critique, being polite and steering people to make it their own idea is less useful than just telling them what is wrong with it. — tap to centre the map on it
In critique, being polite and steering people to make it their own idea is less useful than just telling them what is wrong with it.
Last stated 2 months ago
23 Sept 2026
GT
Geoff Teehan — holds since 2026-09-23 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A self-respecting theoretical physicist kills most of their own ideas rather than waiting for somebody else to do it. — tap to centre the map on it
A self-respecting theoretical physicist kills most of their own ideas rather than waiting for somebody else to do it.
Last stated 2 years ago
5 May 2025
JL
Janna Levin — holds since 2025-05-05 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Critique-and-reply debates in the social sciences are absurdly adversarial; hardly anyone admits an error — tap to centre the map on it
Critique-and-reply debates in the social sciences are absurdly adversarial; hardly anyone admits an error
DK
Daniel Kahneman — holds since c. 2002–2003 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The conversation with a single agent is, in some way, "solved." — tap to centre the map on it
The conversation with a single agent is, in some way, "solved."
Last stated 3 days ago
19 Nov 2026
TB
Thorsten Ball — holds since 2026-11-19 — tap for who they are
Same subject: An agent told to disagree with everything is worthless: it has to form its own view and speak only when that view differs enough to be worth the interruption. — tap to centre the map on it
An agent told to disagree with everything is worthless: it has to form its own view and speak only when that view differs enough to be worth the interruption.
Last stated 3 months ago
9 Aug 2026
SP
Sunil Pai — holds since 2026-08-09 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The archaeological record of early writing is misleading, because people across the Middle East were sending each other messages long before the Sumerians. — tap to centre the map on it
The archaeological record of early writing is misleading, because people across the Middle East were sending each other messages long before the Sumerians.
Last stated 11 months ago
12 Dec 2025
IF
Irving Finkel — holds since 2025-12-12 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The demands of peer reviewers push scientists into producing bad research. — tap to centre the map on it
The demands of peer reviewers push scientists into producing bad research.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Dec 2022
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: People disagreeing about AI capability are speaking past each other, because they are using models of very different tiers on very different kinds of task. — tap to centre the map on it
People disagreeing about AI capability are speaking past each other, because they are using models of very different tiers on very different kinds of task.
Last stated 7 months ago
9 Apr 2026
AK
Andrej Karpathy — holds since 2026-04-09 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A paper written to pass peer review is basically a legal contract and explains the work worse than a plain write-up. — tap to centre the map on it
A paper written to pass peer review is basically a legal contract and explains the work worse than a plain write-up.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Feb 2023
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham. — tap to centre the map on it
A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham.
Last stated a week ago
12 Nov 2026
AD
Andrew Dessler — holds since 2026-11-12 — tap for who they are
Same subject: After Galileo the Inquisition effectively invented peer review, building a second laboratory to recreate experiments' results. — tap to centre the map on it
After Galileo the Inquisition effectively invented peer review, building a second laboratory to recreate experiments' results.
Last stated 9 months ago
6 Mar 2026
AP
Ada Palmer — holds since 2026-03-06 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do. — tap to centre the map on it
Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Feb 2023
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Economics journals have made large datasets and heavy statistics the price of making any causal claim at all, which has squeezed qualitative economic history out of the field. — tap to centre the map on it
Economics journals have made large datasets and heavy statistics the price of making any causal claim at all, which has squeezed qualitative economic history out of the field.
Last stated a year ago
13 Oct 2025
AH
Anton Howes — holds since 2025-10-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Fraudulent papers pass peer review routinely, which is direct evidence that peer review does not do the job it is supposed to do. — tap to centre the map on it
Fraudulent papers pass peer review routinely, which is direct evidence that peer review does not do the job it is supposed to do.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Dec 2022
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The structures of science now have to change, because the scarce thing is no longer proposing theories but verifying and evaluating the thousands anyone can now propose. — tap to centre the map on it
The structures of science now have to change, because the scarce thing is no longer proposing theories but verifying and evaluating the thousands anyone can now propose.
Last stated 8 months ago
20 Mar 2026
TT
Terence Tao — holds since 2026-03-20 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A compound's AI origin story is not by itself a reason to expect it to do better in the clinic. — tap to centre the map on it
A compound's AI origin story is not by itself a reason to expect it to do better in the clinic.
Last stated 3 years ago
13 May 2024
DL
Derek Lowe — holds since 2024-05-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A computational discovery platform does not make a biotech fast, because the thousand other steps of drug development are still the bottleneck. — tap to centre the map on it
A computational discovery platform does not make a biotech fast, because the thousand other steps of drug development are still the bottleneck.
Last stated 2 years ago
17 Sept 2024
AT
Alex Telford — holds since 2024-09-17 — tap for who they are
same subject or similar wording a cloud: claims about one subject, named for it bar: when it was last stated, on a scale from 2015 to today — full is today a face: someone who holds the claim — tap it for who they are
At the centre
It is very rare for scientists who disagree with each other to talk to each other before a critique.
Last stated 17 Mar 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Lisa Feldman Barrett
Read this korrent →
Similar wording
In critique, being polite and steering people to make it their own idea is less useful than just telling them what is wrong with it.
Last stated 23 Sept 2026 · 2 months ago
Holds Geoff Teehan
Similar wording
A self-respecting theoretical physicist kills most of their own ideas rather than waiting for somebody else to do it.
Last stated 5 May 2025 · 2 years ago
Holds Janna Levin
Similar wording
Critique-and-reply debates in the social sciences are absurdly adversarial; hardly anyone admits an error
Last stated c. 2002–2003
Holds Daniel Kahneman
Similar wording
The conversation with a single agent is, in some way, "solved."
Last stated 19 Nov 2026 · 3 days ago
Holds Thorsten Ball
Similar wording
An agent told to disagree with everything is worthless: it has to form its own view and speak only when that view differs enough to be worth the interruption.
Last stated 9 Aug 2026 · 3 months ago
Holds Sunil Pai
Similar wording
The archaeological record of early writing is misleading, because people across the Middle East were sending each other messages long before the Sumerians.
Last stated 12 Dec 2025 · 11 months ago
Holds Irving Finkel
Similar wording
The demands of peer reviewers push scientists into producing bad research.
Last stated 13 Dec 2022 · 4 years ago
Holds Adam Mastroianni
Similar wording
People disagreeing about AI capability are speaking past each other, because they are using models of very different tiers on very different kinds of task.
Last stated 9 Apr 2026 · 7 months ago
Holds Andrej Karpathy
Same subject: peer review
A paper written to pass peer review is basically a legal contract and explains the work worse than a plain write-up.
Last stated 13 Feb 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Adam Mastroianni
Same subject: peer review
A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham.
Last stated 12 Nov 2026 · a week ago
Holds Andrew Dessler
Same subject: peer review
After Galileo the Inquisition effectively invented peer review, building a second laboratory to recreate experiments' results.
Last stated 6 Mar 2026 · 9 months ago
Holds Ada Palmer
Same subject: metascience
Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do.
Last stated 13 Feb 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Adam Mastroianni
Same subject: metascience
Economics journals have made large datasets and heavy statistics the price of making any causal claim at all, which has squeezed qualitative economic history out of the field.
Last stated 13 Oct 2025 · a year ago
Holds Anton Howes
Same subject: metascience
Fraudulent papers pass peer review routinely, which is direct evidence that peer review does not do the job it is supposed to do.
Last stated 13 Dec 2022 · 4 years ago
Holds Adam Mastroianni
Same subject: AI and science
The structures of science now have to change, because the scarce thing is no longer proposing theories but verifying and evaluating the thousands anyone can now propose.
Last stated 20 Mar 2026 · 8 months ago
Holds Terence Tao
Same subject: AI and science
A compound's AI origin story is not by itself a reason to expect it to do better in the clinic.
Last stated 13 May 2024 · 3 years ago
Holds Derek Lowe
Same subject: AI and science
A computational discovery platform does not make a biotech fast, because the thousand other steps of drug development are still the bottleneck.
Last stated 17 Sept 2024 · 2 years ago
Holds Alex Telford