korrents

On the map

Tap a claim on the ring to put it at the centre.

← A review process where authors decide whether and how to address…

17 connected korrents · 15 moments from 4 Feb 2020 to 12 Nov 2026.

Everything filed under peer review peer review Everything filed under metascience metascience Everything filed under climate change climate change Everything filed under agency agency Everything filed under humility humility Same subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subject Read this korrent: A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham. A review process where authors decidewhether and how to address commentswithout an editor is an unscientific sham. Last stated a week ago 12 Nov 2026 AD Andrew Dessler — holds since 2026-11-12 — tap for who they are Same subject: Experts who judge science in public have their reputations at stake in a way anonymous journal reviewers do not. — tap to centre the map on it Experts who judge science in publichave their reputations at stake in away anonymous journal reviewers donot. Last stated 4 years ago 13 Feb 2023 RR Russ Roberts — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are Same subject: It is very rare for scientists who disagree with each other to talk to each other before a critique. — tap to centre the map on it It is very rare for scientists whodisagree with each other to talk toeach other before a critique. Last stated 4 years ago 17 Mar 2023 LB Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-03-17 — tap for who they are Same subject: The strategy used against attribution science is to libel scientists and exaggerate uncertainties to justify inaction. — tap to centre the map on it The strategy used againstattribution science is to libelscientists and exaggerateuncertainties to justify inaction. Last stated 2 weeks ago 5 Nov 2026 AD Andrew Dessler — holds since 2026-11-05 — tap for who they are Same subject: Feedback on research should be something an author can decline, not a condition of publication. — tap to centre the map on it Feedback on research should besomething an author can decline, nota condition of publication. Last stated 4 years ago 13 Feb 2023 AM Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are Same subject: Scientists say they take peer review seriously, but what they actually do shows they do not think it matters. — tap to centre the map on it Scientists say they take peer reviewseriously, but what they actually doshows they do not think it matters. Last stated 4 years ago 13 Dec 2022 AM Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are Same subject: What makes a difference for a reader is not any advice but actually doing their own review. — tap to centre the map on it What makes a difference for a readeris not any advice but actually doingtheir own review. Last stated 2 months ago 1 Oct 2026 TF Tiago Forte — holds since 2026-10-01 — tap for who they are Same subject: Needing a reviewer's approval before an idea counts for anything makes scientists worse at thinking, and costs the field its most unusual ideas. — tap to centre the map on it Needing a reviewer's approval beforean idea counts for anything makesscientists worse at thinking, andcosts the field its most unusualideas. Last stated 4 years ago 13 Dec 2022 AM Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are Same subject: A deep research report should be treated as a first draft and a list of papers to check, never as definitely true. — tap to centre the map on it A deep research report should betreated as a first draft and a listof papers to check, never asdefinitely true. Last stated 2 years ago 27 Feb 2025 AK Andrej Karpathy — holds since 2025-02-27 — tap for who they are Same subject: “Trust science” is a confused instruction: what deserves trust is the process, not any particular thing it has concluded so far. — tap to centre the map on it “Trust science” is a confusedinstruction: what deserves trust isthe process, not any particularthing it has concluded so far. Last stated 3 years ago 16 Aug 2023 JC Jason Crawford — holds since 2023-08-16 — tap for who they are Same subject: A Cochrane Systematic review of 11 trials found no evidence of benefit and a small signal of harm for mechanical CPR devices. — tap to centre the map on it A Cochrane Systematic review of 11trials found no evidence of benefitand a small signal of harm formechanical CPR devices. Last stated 3 months ago 17 Aug 2026 JM John Mandrola — holds since 2026-08-17 — tap for who they are Same subject: A follow-up clinical trial was unable to reproduce the earlier improvement in insulin sensitivity from blueberries. — tap to centre the map on it A follow-up clinical trial wasunable to reproduce the earlierimprovement in insulin sensitivityfrom blueberries. Last stated 2 months ago 6 Oct 2026 RP Rhonda Patrick — holds since 2026-10-06 — tap for who they are Same subject: A paper reporting an AI-generated molecule must publish the model's entire training set in detail, or the result cannot be judged. — tap to centre the map on it A paper reporting an AI-generatedmolecule must publish the model'sentire training set in detail, orthe result cannot be judged. Last stated 7 years ago 4 Feb 2020 DL Derek Lowe — holds since 2020-02-04 — tap for who they are Same subject: Researchers’ prior beliefs about emotion sneak into supposedly objective machine-learning results. — tap to centre the map on it Researchers’ prior beliefs aboutemotion sneak into supposedlyobjective machine-learning results. Last stated 3 weeks ago 30 Oct 2026 LB Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2026-10-30 — tap for who they are Same subject: The current system of incentives for mathematical research will be disturbed by AI. — tap to centre the map on it The current system of incentives formathematical research will bedisturbed by AI. Last stated 4 months ago 26 Jul 2026 TG Timothy Gowers — holds since 2026-07-26 — tap for who they are Same subject: No one should use the specific Saudi Arabian randomized trials on exercise for depression as evidence for medical treatments. — tap to centre the map on it No one should use the specific SaudiArabian randomized trials onexercise for depression as evidencefor medical treatments. Last stated 2 months ago 15 Sept 2026 GM Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz — holds since 2026-09-15 — tap for who they are Same subject: Several impactful studies regarding exercise for depression have serious issues that make them useless as evidence. — tap to centre the map on it Several impactful studies regardingexercise for depression have seriousissues that make them useless asevidence. Last stated 2 months ago 15 Sept 2026 GM Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz — holds since 2026-09-15 — tap for who they are Same subject: Studies that call ketogenic diets superior for fat loss are often misled by weight loss that is really body water. — tap to centre the map on it Studies that call ketogenic dietssuperior for fat loss are oftenmisled by weight loss that is reallybody water. Last stated a month ago 21 Oct 2026 LN Layne Norton — holds since 2026-10-21 — tap for who they are
same subject or similar wordinga cloud: claims about one subject, named for itbar: when it was last stated, on a scale from 2015 to today — full is todaya face: someone who holds the claim — tap it for who they are

At the centre A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham. Last stated 12 Nov 2026 · a week ago Holds Andrew Dessler Read this korrent →