Tap a claim on the ring to put it at the centre.
← Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it…
17 connected korrents · 14 moments from 15 Nov 2019 to 16 Oct 2026.
Everything filed under metascience
metascience
Everything filed under AI and science
AI and science
Everything filed under health and fitness
health and fitness
Everything filed under mathematics
mathematics
Everything filed under humility
humility
Everything filed under agency
agency
Everything filed under peer review
peer review
Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject
Read this korrent: Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do.
Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Feb 2023
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Peer review can be fixed with better practice, such as reviewers looking at the data and journals screening out fraudulent papers — tap to centre the map on it
Peer review can be fixed with better practice, such as reviewers looking at the data and journals screening out fraudulent papers
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Dec 2022
AM
Adam Mastroianni — no longer holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Peer reviewers miss most of the serious errors in the papers they review. — tap to centre the map on it
Peer reviewers miss most of the serious errors in the papers they review.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Dec 2022
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A published finding deserves the reaction 'could be', and knowing whether it is true takes extra effort of one's own. — tap to centre the map on it
A published finding deserves the reaction 'could be', and knowing whether it is true takes extra effort of one's own.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Feb 2023
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A deep research report should be treated as a first draft and a list of papers to check, never as definitely true. — tap to centre the map on it
A deep research report should be treated as a first draft and a list of papers to check, never as definitely true.
Last stated 2 years ago
27 Feb 2025
AK
Andrej Karpathy — holds since 2025-02-27 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Fraudulent papers pass peer review routinely, which is direct evidence that peer review does not do the job it is supposed to do. — tap to centre the map on it
Fraudulent papers pass peer review routinely, which is direct evidence that peer review does not do the job it is supposed to do.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Dec 2022
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2022-12-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: What makes a difference for a reader is not any advice but actually doing their own review. — tap to centre the map on it
What makes a difference for a reader is not any advice but actually doing their own review.
Last stated 2 months ago
1 Oct 2026
TF
Tiago Forte — holds since 2026-10-01 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Most papers are rejected not because they are untrue but because they are judged not interesting or important enough. — tap to centre the map on it
Most papers are rejected not because they are untrue but because they are judged not interesting or important enough.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Feb 2023
RR
Russ Roberts — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The full picture of a scientific debate is almost always more complex than a skim of the abstracts, so it is worth checking the actual data. — tap to centre the map on it
The full picture of a scientific debate is almost always more complex than a skim of the abstracts, so it is worth checking the actual data.
Last stated 9 months ago
19 Feb 2026
AH
Alex Hutchinson — holds since 2026-02-19 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A compound's AI origin story is not by itself a reason to expect it to do better in the clinic. — tap to centre the map on it
A compound's AI origin story is not by itself a reason to expect it to do better in the clinic.
Last stated 3 years ago
13 May 2024
DL
Derek Lowe — holds since 2024-05-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A computational discovery platform does not make a biotech fast, because the thousand other steps of drug development are still the bottleneck. — tap to centre the map on it
A computational discovery platform does not make a biotech fast, because the thousand other steps of drug development are still the bottleneck.
Last stated 2 years ago
17 Sept 2024
AT
Alex Telford — holds since 2024-09-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A computational method can regularly predict protein structures with atomic accuracy even when no similar structure is known. — tap to centre the map on it
A computational method can regularly predict protein structures with atomic accuracy even when no similar structure is known.
Last stated 5 years ago
15 Jul 2021
DH
Demis Hassabis — holds since 2021-07-15 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A basic week might be about 60 percent weight training and 40 percent conditioning. — tap to centre the map on it
A basic week might be about 60 percent weight training and 40 percent conditioning.
Last stated 4 years ago
4 Jul 2022
JC
Jeff Cavaliere — holds since 2022-07-04 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A celebrated popular science book can consistently misrepresent the literature it summarises and contradict its own sources. — tap to centre the map on it
A celebrated popular science book can consistently misrepresent the literature it summarises and contradict its own sources.
Last stated 7 years ago
15 Nov 2019
AG
Alexey Guzey — holds since 2019-11-15 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A conclusion being biologically reasonable is not the same as its having been proven. — tap to centre the map on it
A conclusion being biologically reasonable is not the same as its having been proven.
Last stated 4 months ago
11 Jul 2026
PA
Peter Attia — holds since 2026-07-11 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A math research career will continue to exist, may be more useful than ever, and will be joyful. — tap to centre the map on it
A math research career will continue to exist, may be more useful than ever, and will be joyful.
Last stated a month ago
16 Oct 2026
GS
Grant Sanderson — holds since 2026-10-16 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A persistently rising dividend yield eventually forces capital appreciation as the market rerates the stock. — tap to centre the map on it
A persistently rising dividend yield eventually forces capital appreciation as the market rerates the stock.
Last stated 9 months ago
3 Mar 2026
SB
Sanjay Bakshi — holds since 2026-03-03 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A proof and an explanation are different things, and a theorem can stay an unsolved expository problem long after it is proved. — tap to centre the map on it
A proof and an explanation are different things, and a theorem can stay an unsolved expository problem long after it is proved.
Last stated 5 months ago
30 Jun 2026
GS
Grant Sanderson — holds since 2026-06-30 — tap for who they are
same subject or similar wording a cloud: claims about one subject, named for it bar: when it was last stated, on a scale from 2015 to today — full is today a face: someone who holds the claim — tap it for who they are faded, dashed ring: they no longer hold it — they changed their mind