korrents

On the map

Tap a claim on the ring to put it at the centre.

← There is little reason to believe in the importance of g, the general…

17 connected korrents · 18 moments from 18 Oct 2007 to 3 Sept 2026.

Everything filed under measuring intelligence measuring intelligence Everything filed under AGI AGI Everything filed under benchmarks benchmarks Everything filed under LLMs LLMs Everything filed under ARC-AGI ARC-AGI Everything filed under ideas vs execution ideas vs execution Same subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subjectSame subject Read this korrent: There is little reason to believe in the importance of g, the general factor of intelligence, and many reasons to reject it. There is little reason to believe in theimportance of g, the general factor ofintelligence, and many reasons to rejectit. Last stated 19 years ago 18 Oct 2007 CS Cosma Rohilla Shalizi — holds since 2007-10-18 — tap for who they are Same subject: Factor analysis cannot reveal causal structure, so it provides no support for the reality of g, the general factor of intelligence. — tap to centre the map on it Factor analysis cannot reveal causalstructure, so it provides no supportfor the reality of g, the generalfactor of intelligence. Last stated 19 years ago 18 Oct 2007 CS Cosma Rohilla Shalizi — holds since 2007-10-18 — tap for who they are Same subject: Purely conceptual reasoning about AI psychology, without empirical work or hard math, is unlikely to get very far. — tap to centre the map on it Purely conceptual reasoning about AIpsychology, without empirical workor hard math, is unlikely to getvery far. Last stated 4 years ago 12 May 2023 AC Ajeya Cotra — holds since 2023-05-12 — tap for who they are Same subject: What has actually been under selection is probably not intelligence but a general trait more like executive function or the propensity to defer gratification. — tap to centre the map on it What has actually been underselection is probably notintelligence but a general traitmore like executive function or thepropensity to defer gratification. Last stated 7 months ago 8 May 2026 DR David Reich — holds since 2026-05-08 — tap for who they are Same subject: A vastly superhuman intelligence would still not be able to talk people out of their beliefs, because humans are barely persuadable. — tap to centre the map on it A vastly superhuman intelligencewould still not be able to talkpeople out of their beliefs, becausehumans are barely persuadable. Last stated a year ago 21 Aug 2025 DY Dynomight — holds since 2025-03-27 — tap for who they are DY Dynomight — no longer holds since 2025-08-21 — tap for who they are Same subject: General intelligence (g) reflects an overall pool of neural resources rooted in whole-body developmental integrity, making it a large mutational target rather than a distinct cognitive module. — tap to centre the map on it General intelligence (g) reflects anoverall pool of neural resourcesrooted in whole-body developmentalintegrity, making it a largemutational target rather than adistinct cognitive module. Last stated 5 years ago 11 Jun 2021 GW Gwern — holds since 2021-06-11 — tap for who they are Same subject: Developing AGI is a problem of philosophy, not computer science or neurophysiology. — tap to centre the map on it Developing AGI is a problem ofphilosophy, not computer science orneurophysiology. Last stated 14 years ago 3 Oct 2012 DD David Deutsch — holds since 2012-10-03 — tap for who they are Same subject: What any individual human can do comes from collectively built scaffolding rather than from the individual, and AGI may turn out to be more like that scaffolding than like a single brain. — tap to centre the map on it What any individual human can docomes from collectively builtscaffolding rather than from theindividual, and AGI may turn out tobe more like that scaffolding thanlike a single brain. Last stated 3 years ago 18 Mar 2024 SA Sam Altman — holds since 2024-03-18 — tap for who they are Same subject: People are too quick to leap from AGI for desk jobs to superintelligence or to AGI for physical labour. — tap to centre the map on it People are too quick to leap fromAGI for desk jobs tosuperintelligence or to AGI forphysical labour. Last stated a year ago 13 Aug 2025 NS Nate Silver — holds since 2025-08-13 — tap for who they are Same subject: Combining an avocado and a chair into one image is evidence a model conceptually understands both, not that it memorised pictures of them. — tap to centre the map on it Combining an avocado and a chairinto one image is evidence a modelconceptually understands both, notthat it memorised pictures of them. Last stated 3 months ago 12 Aug 2026 CF Chelsea Finn — holds since 2026-08-12 — tap for who they are Same subject: Passing ARC-AGI does not amount to achieving AGI: o3 still fails on some very easy tasks, indicating fundamental differences from human intelligence. — tap to centre the map on it Passing ARC-AGI does not amount toachieving AGI: o3 still fails onsome very easy tasks, indicatingfundamental differences from humanintelligence. Last stated 2 years ago 20 Dec 2024 FC François Chollet — holds since 2024-12-20 — tap for who they are Same subject: The Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus can measure human-like general fluid intelligence and enable fair comparisons between AI systems and humans. — tap to centre the map on it The Abstraction and Reasoning Corpuscan measure human-like general fluidintelligence and enable faircomparisons between AI systems andhumans. Last stated 7 years ago 5 Nov 2019 FC François Chollet — holds since 2019-11-05 — tap for who they are Same subject: "Return on tokens" has the same measurement problems as hours and capacity: it still hinges on a theory of value. — tap to centre the map on it "Return on tokens" has the samemeasurement problems as hours andcapacity: it still hinges on atheory of value. Last stated 3 months ago 17 Aug 2026 JC John Cutler — holds since 2026-08-17 — tap for who they are Same subject: A badly written AI outbound email is evidence of a bad vendor, not of a limit of AI. — tap to centre the map on it A badly written AI outbound email isevidence of a bad vendor, not of alimit of AI. Last stated 11 months ago 1 Jan 2026 JL Jason Lemkin — holds since 2026-01-01 — tap for who they are Same subject: A base model is essentially a very expensive autocomplete that continues text according to the statistics of its training documents. — tap to centre the map on it A base model is essentially a veryexpensive autocomplete thatcontinues text according to thestatistics of its trainingdocuments. Last stated 2 years ago 5 Feb 2025 AK Andrej Karpathy — holds since 2025-02-05 — tap for who they are Same subject: 'Everyone gets it wrong sometimes' is a bad argument when assessing track records. — tap to centre the map on it 'Everyone gets it wrong sometimes'is a bad argument when assessingtrack records. Last stated 4 months ago 2 Aug 2026 AK Adam Kucharski — holds since 2026-08-02 — tap for who they are Same subject: A benchmark result should be reported under a stated budget, or as a curve against test-time compute — never as a single number. — tap to centre the map on it A benchmark result should bereported under a stated budget, oras a curve against test-time compute— never as a single number. Last stated 5 months ago 26 Jun 2026 NB Noam Brown — holds since 2026-06-26 — tap for who they are Same subject: A benchmark that ranks Claude Code last while it stays first in use is measuring the wrong thing, and has been for a year. — tap to centre the map on it A benchmark that ranks Claude Codelast while it stays first in use ismeasuring the wrong thing, and hasbeen for a year. Last stated 3 months ago 3 Sept 2026 DR Dax Raad — holds since 2026-09-03 — tap for who they are
same subject or similar wordinga cloud: claims about one subject, named for itbar: when it was last stated, on a scale from 2007 to today (stretched back to the oldest claim here) — full is todaya face: someone who holds the claim — tap it for who they arefaded, dashed ring: they no longer hold it — they changed their mind

At the centre There is little reason to believe in the importance of g, the general factor of intelligence, and many reasons to reject it. Last stated 18 Oct 2007 · 19 years ago Holds Cosma Rohilla Shalizi Read this korrent →