korrents

EMDR

Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing: a trauma therapy in which the patient recalls a memory while moving their eyes from side to side. Recommended as a first-line PTSD treatment; whether the eye movements themselves do anything is still argued about.

What people on korrents have said about EMDR, newest first — 4 positions from 2 people.

FilterEveryone, all time
  1. SM

    Scott D. Miller quoted

    A therapy is only shown to be more effective if it is compared against another treatment intended to help, not against a control nobody expected to work.

    If one really wanted to know whether a treatment (e.g., CBT, IPT, ACT, EMDR) was more effective, it had to be directly compared to an approach intended to help - what Wampold and colleagues termed, a "bona fide" treatment. Doing otherwise, they argued, conflated artifacts of research design with actual research results.

    Results from the first bona fide study of deliberate practicewritings.scottdmiller.com

    PsychotherapyCBT

  2. 2 years earlier
  3. SA

    Scott Alexander quoted

    Somebody with trauma should try a trauma-focused therapy such as EMDR before treating their nightmares directly.

    I would recommend that anyone who thinks they're suffering from trauma (eg PTSD) try a trauma-focused therapy like EMDR before trying to address nightmares directly, unless the nightmares are overwhelmingly worse than all their other trauma symptoms.

    Peer Review: Nightmaresastralcodexten.com

    PsychotherapyTrauma

  4. 16 months earlier
  5. SA

    Scott Alexander quoted

    If negative emotion comes from underweighting sensory evidence, that explains EMDR: it forces high-precision attention onto something the mind usually represses.

    First, it justifies various psychotherapies - EMDR and coherence therapy seem to come out especially well here - that focus on trying to get the brain to pay unusually precise attention, under unusually safe conditions, to something it usually represses.

    The Precision Of Sensory Evidenceastralcodexten.com

    Psychotherapy

  6. 15 months earlier
  7. SA

    Scott Alexander quoted

    Eye movement reprocessing went from alternative to establishment, and moving your eyes while talking about a trauma does seem to help you process it.

    Eye movement directed reprocessing (alternative when the book was written, now basically establishment) where you move your eyes back and forth while talking about your trauma, and this seems to somehow help you process it better.

    Book Review: The Body Keeps The Scoreslatestarcodex.com

    Trauma