Tap a claim on the ring to put it at the centre.
← The field of emotion research is a bit sloppy about keeping evidence and interpretation distinct.
17 connected korrents · 11 moments from 13 Feb 2023 to 12 Nov 2026.
Everything filed under metascience
metascience
Everything filed under behavioural science
behavioural science
Everything filed under politics
politics
Everything filed under consciousness
consciousness
Everything filed under AI sentience
AI sentience
Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject
Read this korrent: The field of emotion research is a bit sloppy about keeping evidence and interpretation distinct.
The field of emotion research is a bit sloppy about keeping evidence and interpretation distinct.
Last stated 4 years ago
1 May 2023
LB
Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-05-01 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The basic emotion view is not responsive to evidence. — tap to centre the map on it
The basic emotion view is not responsive to evidence.
Last stated 4 years ago
1 May 2023
LB
Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-05-01 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Emotion categories show variation within and similarity across them, so their boundaries are not firm. — tap to centre the map on it
Emotion categories show variation within and similarity across them, so their boundaries are not firm.
Last stated 4 years ago
17 Mar 2023
LB
Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-03-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Emotions do not meet the criteria for natural kind categories according to anyone's research. — tap to centre the map on it
Emotions do not meet the criteria for natural kind categories according to anyone's research.
Last stated 4 years ago
17 Mar 2023
LB
Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-03-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Criticisms of the basic emotion approach may apply only to certain theories within that framework, not to all of them. — tap to centre the map on it
Criticisms of the basic emotion approach may apply only to certain theories within that framework, not to all of them.
Last stated 4 years ago
1 May 2023
LB
Lisa Feldman Barrett — holds since 2023-05-01 — tap for who they are
Same subject: One good story outweighs a mountain of evidence, because most emotions cannot be argued with. — tap to centre the map on it
One good story outweighs a mountain of evidence, because most emotions cannot be argued with.
Last stated 10 months ago
20 Jan 2026
DS
Derek Sivers — holds since 2026-01-20 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Equating an emotion with the conscious feeling of it turns emotion research into consciousness research, which is why the two must be kept apart. — tap to centre the map on it
Equating an emotion with the conscious feeling of it turns emotion research into consciousness research, which is why the two must be kept apart.
Last stated 3 months ago
17 Aug 2026
RA
Ralph Adolphs — holds since 2026-08-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: You cannot reliably tell how someone feels from their facial expression, and Ekman's universality claim does not survive a reading of the whole literature. — tap to centre the map on it
You cannot reliably tell how someone feels from their facial expression, and Ekman's universality claim does not survive a reading of the whole literature.
Last stated 3 months ago
17 Aug 2026
RA
Ralph Adolphs — holds since 2026-08-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Functionally defined emotions can be attributed to animals and, to some extent, to AI systems, without any claim about what either of them feels. — tap to centre the map on it
Functionally defined emotions can be attributed to animals and, to some extent, to AI systems, without any claim about what either of them feels.
Last stated 3 months ago
17 Aug 2026
RA
Ralph Adolphs — holds since 2026-08-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: “Trust science” is a confused instruction: what deserves trust is the process, not any particular thing it has concluded so far. — tap to centre the map on it
“Trust science” is a confused instruction: what deserves trust is the process, not any particular thing it has concluded so far.
Last stated 3 years ago
16 Aug 2023
JC
Jason Crawford — holds since 2023-08-16 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A Cochrane Systematic review of 11 trials found no evidence of benefit and a small signal of harm for mechanical CPR devices. — tap to centre the map on it
A Cochrane Systematic review of 11 trials found no evidence of benefit and a small signal of harm for mechanical CPR devices.
Last stated 3 months ago
17 Aug 2026
JM
John Mandrola — holds since 2026-08-17 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A follow-up clinical trial was unable to reproduce the earlier improvement in insulin sensitivity from blueberries. — tap to centre the map on it
A follow-up clinical trial was unable to reproduce the earlier improvement in insulin sensitivity from blueberries.
Last stated 2 months ago
6 Oct 2026
RP
Rhonda Patrick — holds since 2026-10-06 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham. — tap to centre the map on it
A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham.
Last stated a week ago
12 Nov 2026
AD
Andrew Dessler — holds since 2026-11-12 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do. — tap to centre the map on it
Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do.
Last stated 4 years ago
13 Feb 2023
AM
Adam Mastroianni — holds since 2023-02-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Economics journals have made large datasets and heavy statistics the price of making any causal claim at all, which has squeezed qualitative economic history out of the field. — tap to centre the map on it
Economics journals have made large datasets and heavy statistics the price of making any causal claim at all, which has squeezed qualitative economic history out of the field.
Last stated a year ago
13 Oct 2025
AH
Anton Howes — holds since 2025-10-13 — tap for who they are
Same subject: No one should use the specific Saudi Arabian randomized trials on exercise for depression as evidence for medical treatments. — tap to centre the map on it
No one should use the specific Saudi Arabian randomized trials on exercise for depression as evidence for medical treatments.
Last stated 2 months ago
15 Sept 2026
GM
Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz — holds since 2026-09-15 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Several impactful studies regarding exercise for depression have serious issues that make them useless as evidence. — tap to centre the map on it
Several impactful studies regarding exercise for depression have serious issues that make them useless as evidence.
Last stated 2 months ago
15 Sept 2026
GM
Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz — holds since 2026-09-15 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Studies that call ketogenic diets superior for fat loss are often misled by weight loss that is really body water. — tap to centre the map on it
Studies that call ketogenic diets superior for fat loss are often misled by weight loss that is really body water.
Last stated a month ago
21 Oct 2026
LN
Layne Norton — holds since 2026-10-21 — tap for who they are
same subject or similar wording a cloud: claims about one subject, named for it bar: when it was last stated, on a scale from 2015 to today — full is today a face: someone who holds the claim — tap it for who they are
At the centre
The field of emotion research is a bit sloppy about keeping evidence and interpretation distinct.
Last stated 1 May 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Lisa Feldman Barrett
Read this korrent →
Similar wording
The basic emotion view is not responsive to evidence.
Last stated 1 May 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Lisa Feldman Barrett
Similar wording
Emotion categories show variation within and similarity across them, so their boundaries are not firm.
Last stated 17 Mar 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Lisa Feldman Barrett
Similar wording
Emotions do not meet the criteria for natural kind categories according to anyone's research.
Last stated 17 Mar 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Lisa Feldman Barrett
Similar wording
Criticisms of the basic emotion approach may apply only to certain theories within that framework, not to all of them.
Last stated 1 May 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Lisa Feldman Barrett
Similar wording
One good story outweighs a mountain of evidence, because most emotions cannot be argued with.
Last stated 20 Jan 2026 · 10 months ago
Holds Derek Sivers
Similar wording
Equating an emotion with the conscious feeling of it turns emotion research into consciousness research, which is why the two must be kept apart.
Last stated 17 Aug 2026 · 3 months ago
Holds Ralph Adolphs
Similar wording
You cannot reliably tell how someone feels from their facial expression, and Ekman's universality claim does not survive a reading of the whole literature.
Last stated 17 Aug 2026 · 3 months ago
Holds Ralph Adolphs
Similar wording
Functionally defined emotions can be attributed to animals and, to some extent, to AI systems, without any claim about what either of them feels.
Last stated 17 Aug 2026 · 3 months ago
Holds Ralph Adolphs
Same subject: metascience
“Trust science” is a confused instruction: what deserves trust is the process, not any particular thing it has concluded so far.
Last stated 16 Aug 2023 · 3 years ago
Holds Jason Crawford
Same subject: metascience
A Cochrane Systematic review of 11 trials found no evidence of benefit and a small signal of harm for mechanical CPR devices.
Last stated 17 Aug 2026 · 3 months ago
Holds John Mandrola
Same subject: metascience
A follow-up clinical trial was unable to reproduce the earlier improvement in insulin sensitivity from blueberries.
Last stated 6 Oct 2026 · 2 months ago
Holds Rhonda Patrick
Same subject: peer review
A review process where authors decide whether and how to address comments without an editor is an unscientific sham.
Last stated 12 Nov 2026 · a week ago
Holds Andrew Dessler
Same subject: peer review
Checking a paper's data and analysis is almost never done, though it may be the most important thing review could do.
Last stated 13 Feb 2023 · 4 years ago
Holds Adam Mastroianni
Same subject: peer review
Economics journals have made large datasets and heavy statistics the price of making any causal claim at all, which has squeezed qualitative economic history out of the field.
Last stated 13 Oct 2025 · a year ago
Holds Anton Howes
Same subject: health and fitness
No one should use the specific Saudi Arabian randomized trials on exercise for depression as evidence for medical treatments.
Last stated 15 Sept 2026 · 2 months ago
Holds Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz
Same subject: health and fitness
Several impactful studies regarding exercise for depression have serious issues that make them useless as evidence.
Last stated 15 Sept 2026 · 2 months ago
Holds Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz
Same subject: health and fitness
Studies that call ketogenic diets superior for fat loss are often misled by weight loss that is really body water.
Last stated 21 Oct 2026 · a month ago
Holds Layne Norton