Tap a claim on the ring to put it at the centre.
← Outside psychiatry, mental illness is too often whatever psychiatrists say it is
17 connected korrents · 15 moments from 4 Aug 2010 to 31 Oct 2026.
Everything filed under Psychotherapy
Psychotherapy
Everything filed under Trauma
Trauma
Everything filed under CBT
CBT
Everything filed under EMDR
EMDR
Everything filed under mental models
mental models
Everything filed under epidemiology
epidemiology
Everything filed under humility
humility
Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject Same subject
Read this korrent: Outside psychiatry, mental illness is too often whatever psychiatrists say it is
Outside psychiatry, mental illness is too often whatever psychiatrists say it is
TS
Thomas Szasz — holds since c. 1961 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Mental illness is a myth — tap to centre the map on it
Mental illness is a myth
TS
Thomas Szasz — holds since c. 1961 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Psychiatrists do not actually deal with mental illnesses and their treatment — tap to centre the map on it
Psychiatrists do not actually deal with mental illnesses and their treatment
TS
Thomas Szasz — holds since c. 1961 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The current approach to mental health labelling and diagnosis may be doing more harm than good. — tap to centre the map on it
The current approach to mental health labelling and diagnosis may be doing more harm than good.
Last stated 9 months ago
10 Feb 2026
GF
Gavin Francis — holds since 2026-02-10 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Mental health practitioners will have to deal with clients and patients who have very different kinds of minds. — tap to centre the map on it
Mental health practitioners will have to deal with clients and patients who have very different kinds of minds.
Last stated 3 weeks ago
31 Oct 2026
ML
Michael Levin — holds since 2026-10-31 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The overdiagnosis of mental illness should not be treated as a yes/no question, since several things can be happening at once. — tap to centre the map on it
The overdiagnosis of mental illness should not be treated as a yes/no question, since several things can be happening at once.
Last stated 9 months ago
23 Feb 2026
LF
Lucy Foulkes — holds since 2026-02-23 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The apparent rise in mental illness is, at first pass, an artifact of measurement and the medicalization of society. — tap to centre the map on it
The apparent rise in mental illness is, at first pass, an artifact of measurement and the medicalization of society.
Last stated 4 years ago
20 Oct 2022
BC
Bryan Caplan — holds since 2022-10-20 — tap for who they are
Same subject: No approach to mental healthcare exceeds being highly imperfect, and anyone claiming otherwise is dishonest or mistaken. — tap to centre the map on it
No approach to mental healthcare exceeds being highly imperfect, and anyone claiming otherwise is dishonest or mistaken.
Last stated 2 months ago
19 Sept 2026
AA
Awais Aftab — holds since 2026-09-19 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Psychiatry's confidence in its theories of mind and brain exceeds the evidence supporting them. — tap to centre the map on it
Psychiatry's confidence in its theories of mind and brain exceeds the evidence supporting them.
Last stated 2 months ago
12 Sept 2026
AA
Awais Aftab — holds since 2026-09-12 — tap for who they are
Same subject: EMDR targets specific memories well but is not built for identity work or building a life narrative. — tap to centre the map on it
EMDR targets specific memories well but is not built for identity work or building a life narrative.
Last stated 8 months ago
7 Apr 2026
AW
Annie Wright — holds since 2026-04-07 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Eye movement reprocessing went from alternative to establishment, and moving your eyes while talking about a trauma does seem to help you process it. — tap to centre the map on it
Eye movement reprocessing went from alternative to establishment, and moving your eyes while talking about a trauma does seem to help you process it.
Last stated 7 years ago
12 Nov 2019
SA
Scott Alexander — holds since 2019-11-12 — tap for who they are
Same subject: The eye movement in EMDR came from a chance observation, not a theory. — tap to centre the map on it
The eye movement in EMDR came from a chance observation, not a theory.
Last stated 16 years ago
19 Mar 2011
FS
Francine Shapiro — holds since 2011-03-19 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Acting opposite to an emotion-driven urge, such as reaching out when one wants to isolate, can be very effective. — tap to centre the map on it
Acting opposite to an emotion-driven urge, such as reaching out when one wants to isolate, can be very effective.
Last stated 2 years ago
24 Nov 2024
AW
Annie Wright — holds since 2024-11-24 — tap for who they are
Same subject: Action comes before motivation: you do first and feel afterwards, not the other way round. — tap to centre the map on it
Action comes before motivation: you do first and feel afterwards, not the other way round.
Last stated a year ago
30 Sept 2025
LF
Lex Fridman — holds since 2025-09-30 — tap for who they are
Same subject: CBT helps people cope but does not reach the core problems people have. — tap to centre the map on it
CBT helps people cope but does not reach the core problems people have.
Last stated 16 years ago
4 Aug 2010
LG
Leslie Greenberg — holds since 2010-08-04 — tap for who they are
Same subject: "The body keeps the score" is only half the story, and the missing half matters: a body described only as a harbinger of the past is a body people learn to avoid. — tap to centre the map on it
"The body keeps the score" is only half the story, and the missing half matters: a body described only as a harbinger of the past is a body people learn to avoid.
Last stated 3 months ago
25 Aug 2026
AS
Arielle Schwartz — holds since 2026-08-25 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A broader understanding of relational trauma is crucial for validating abuse that happened in less recognised contexts. — tap to centre the map on it
A broader understanding of relational trauma is crucial for validating abuse that happened in less recognised contexts.
Last stated 2 years ago
15 Sept 2024
AW
Annie Wright — holds since 2024-09-15 — tap for who they are
Same subject: A substantial share of people's personalities, dispositions, and dysfunctions is genetically driven rather than purely a product of environment or trauma. — tap to centre the map on it
A substantial share of people's personalities, dispositions, and dysfunctions is genetically driven rather than purely a product of environment or trauma.
Last stated 3 years ago
22 Feb 2024
MM
Mark Manson — holds since 2024-02-22 — tap for who they are
same subject or similar wording a cloud: claims about one subject, named for it bar: when it was last stated, on a scale from 2010 to today (stretched back to the oldest claim here) — full is today a face: someone who holds the claim — tap it for who they are
At the centre
Outside psychiatry, mental illness is too often whatever psychiatrists say it is
Last stated c. 1961
Holds Thomas Szasz
Read this korrent →
Similar wording
Mental illness is a myth
Last stated c. 1961
Holds Thomas Szasz
Similar wording
Psychiatrists do not actually deal with mental illnesses and their treatment
Last stated c. 1961
Holds Thomas Szasz
Similar wording
The current approach to mental health labelling and diagnosis may be doing more harm than good.
Last stated 10 Feb 2026 · 9 months ago
Holds Gavin Francis
Similar wording
Mental health practitioners will have to deal with clients and patients who have very different kinds of minds.
Last stated 31 Oct 2026 · 3 weeks ago
Holds Michael Levin
Similar wording
The overdiagnosis of mental illness should not be treated as a yes/no question, since several things can be happening at once.
Last stated 23 Feb 2026 · 9 months ago
Holds Lucy Foulkes
Similar wording
The apparent rise in mental illness is, at first pass, an artifact of measurement and the medicalization of society.
Last stated 20 Oct 2022 · 4 years ago
Holds Bryan Caplan
Similar wording
No approach to mental healthcare exceeds being highly imperfect, and anyone claiming otherwise is dishonest or mistaken.
Last stated 19 Sept 2026 · 2 months ago
Holds Awais Aftab
Similar wording
Psychiatry's confidence in its theories of mind and brain exceeds the evidence supporting them.
Last stated 12 Sept 2026 · 2 months ago
Holds Awais Aftab
Same subject: EMDR
EMDR targets specific memories well but is not built for identity work or building a life narrative.
Last stated 7 Apr 2026 · 8 months ago
Holds Annie Wright
Same subject: EMDR
Eye movement reprocessing went from alternative to establishment, and moving your eyes while talking about a trauma does seem to help you process it.
Last stated 12 Nov 2019 · 7 years ago
Holds Scott Alexander
Same subject: EMDR
The eye movement in EMDR came from a chance observation, not a theory.
Last stated 19 Mar 2011 · 16 years ago
Holds Francine Shapiro
Same subject: CBT
Acting opposite to an emotion-driven urge, such as reaching out when one wants to isolate, can be very effective.
Last stated 24 Nov 2024 · 2 years ago
Holds Annie Wright
Same subject: CBT
Action comes before motivation: you do first and feel afterwards, not the other way round.
Last stated 30 Sept 2025 · a year ago
Holds Lex Fridman
Same subject: CBT
CBT helps people cope but does not reach the core problems people have.
Last stated 4 Aug 2010 · 16 years ago
Holds Leslie Greenberg
Same subject: Trauma
"The body keeps the score" is only half the story, and the missing half matters: a body described only as a harbinger of the past is a body people learn to avoid.
Last stated 25 Aug 2026 · 3 months ago
Holds Arielle Schwartz
Same subject: Trauma
A broader understanding of relational trauma is crucial for validating abuse that happened in less recognised contexts.
Last stated 15 Sept 2024 · 2 years ago
Holds Annie Wright
Same subject: Trauma
A substantial share of people's personalities, dispositions, and dysfunctions is genetically driven rather than purely a product of environment or trauma.
Last stated 22 Feb 2024 · 3 years ago
Holds Mark Manson