What Russ Roberts thinks about peer review
Economist; hosts EconTalk, the weekly long-form interview podcast he started in 2006.
Russ Roberts did not write this page.
We collected these quotes from things they published elsewhere, and every quote links to where it was said. They have no account here and have not endorsed this site. Quotes are word for word; the short line under each one is our own restatement, not their wording. Their own site. Is this you? Claim it or ask us to remove it. Or tell us what is wrong here.
Filter peer review · Newest first
Only Russ Roberts on peer review. See everyone on peer review
5 dated positions, 2023, in their own words. Our reading of what Russ Roberts has said — not written or endorsed by them.
-
Their wordsmost of the time papers are not rejected because they're not true. They're rejected because they're not interesting, or they're not profound, or the results are not sufficiently important.
↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org 5th of 38 in this recording
-
Their wordsBut this replication crisis--which again, I think its home base is in psychology, but it's spreading much more widely--is, it's kind of dramatic. It's not a very good system, the idea of peer review.
↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org 9th of 38 in this recording
-
Their wordsthere's a long list of books that claim to give us the latest science on various aspects of life. And, that science is always peer-reviewed journal articles, many of which are false. And yet people are reading them thinking they're true
↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org 12th of 38 in this recording
-
Their wordsBut, I think the beauty of so-called science is that the experts who might vet or opine on scientific reliability have reputational things at stake that are not present when they are anonymous reviewers for obscure journal.
↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org 28th of 38 in this recording
-
Their wordsMost scholars work on tiny things that are not relatively important. And, that's tragedy. That's worse than the 15,000 hours on reviewing.
↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org 32nd of 38 in this recording