korrents
Russ Roberts

Russ Roberts

@russ-roberts · 23 positions · On ppll ↗

Economist; hosts EconTalk, the weekly long-form interview podcast he started in 2006.

Russ Roberts did not write this page.

We collected these quotes from things they published elsewhere, and every quote links to where it was said. They have no account here and have not endorsed this site. Quotes are word for word; the short line under each one is our own restatement, not their wording. Their own site. Is this you? Claim it or ask us to remove it. Or tell us what is wrong here.

The ideas Russ Roberts's claims keep coming back to. The labels are ours; every quote is Russ Roberts's own words.

Holds now (3)

How these views changed over time2021–2023
Sort
Show

Each column is a stretch of time in which the same views came up; a new column starts when one appears or goes quiet. Quiet means nothing on it in our sources for that stretch, which is not the same as a change of mind; Dropped means they said they no longer hold it; tap the card for which claim and when. Revised means the view carries on but one of its claims was dropped. Each row is one view, in the same place all the way along. The number is how many claims in that stretch; we hold 10 in 2021, 0 in 2022, 13 in 2023.

Peer review and publish-or-perish make science less reliable and less bold

Our label. 6 claims in Russ Roberts's own words.

Most papers are rejected not because they are untrue but because they are judged not interesting or important enough.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk most of the time papers are not rejected because they're not true. They're rejected because they're not interesting, or they're not profound, or the results are not sufficiently important. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:04:38 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    most of the time papers are not rejected because they're not true. They're rejected because they're not interesting, or they're not profound, or the results are not sufficiently important.

    Said 0:04:38 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

The replication crisis, centred in psychology but spreading, shows that peer review is not a very good system.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk But this replication crisis--which again, I think its home base is in psychology, but it's spreading much more widely--is, it's kind of dramatic. It's not a very good system, the idea of peer review. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:25:31 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    But this replication crisis--which again, I think its home base is in psychology, but it's spreading much more widely--is, it's kind of dramatic. It's not a very good system, the idea of peer review.

    Said 0:25:31 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

The pressure to publish pushes academics toward smaller, safer questions, and most academics are not risk-takers.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk there's a huge incentive to publish. And, that quote changes everything. I mean, it changes what you think about, how you think about it. It pushes you towards smaller thoughts and smaller questions because the return is more--safer. And, most people in academics are not risk-takers. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:45:47 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    there's a huge incentive to publish. And, that quote changes everything. I mean, it changes what you think about, how you think about it. It pushes you towards smaller thoughts and smaller questions because the return is more--safer. And, most people in academics are not risk-takers.

    Said 0:45:47 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

Most scholars work on relatively unimportant things, which is a tragedy worse than the hours spent reviewing.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk Most scholars work on tiny things that are not relatively important. And, that's tragedy. That's worse than the 15,000 hours on reviewing. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:53:24 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    Most scholars work on tiny things that are not relatively important. And, that's tragedy. That's worse than the 15,000 hours on reviewing.

    Said 0:53:24 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

There are far too many PhDs today, though an open system of publishing might still work.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk There are things that are different. As I said, there's way too many Ph.D.s, but maybe it'll work. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 1:01:25 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    There are things that are different. As I said, there's way too many Ph.D.s, but maybe it'll work.

    Said 1:01:25 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

Information only helps if you know how much to trust it

Our label. 5 claims in Russ Roberts's own words.

More information helps only if it can be weighed properly; overconfidence in imperfect information produces a different kind of error.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk More information is better only if you can weigh it properly. Only if you can assess it properly. If you overreact to it, if you are overly confident in the information, the imperfect information you get, you make a different kind of error. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:34:14 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    More information is better only if you can weigh it properly. Only if you can assess it properly. If you overreact to it, if you are overly confident in the information, the imperfect information you get, you make a different kind of error.

    Said 0:34:14 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

The alternative to trusting empirical findings is not the gut but understanding that the information you have is not always reliable.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk people say, 'Well, what's the alternative? Using your gut?' And, the answer is, 'No. It's understanding that the information you have is not always reliable.' Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:34:14 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    people say, 'Well, what's the alternative? Using your gut?' And, the answer is, 'No. It's understanding that the information you have is not always reliable.'

    Said 0:34:14 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

Priming research never passed the sniff test, and it has turned out not to pass the replication test either.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk I've always found not to pass the sniff test. But it turns out it doesn't pass the replication test. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:30:01 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    I've always found not to pass the sniff test. But it turns out it doesn't pass the replication test.

    Said 0:30:01 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

Experts who judge science in public have their reputations at stake in a way anonymous journal reviewers do not.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk But, I think the beauty of so-called science is that the experts who might vet or opine on scientific reliability have reputational things at stake that are not present when they are anonymous reviewers for obscure journal. Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 0:50:51 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    But, I think the beauty of so-called science is that the experts who might vet or opine on scientific reliability have reputational things at stake that are not present when they are anonymous reviewers for obscure journal.

    Said 0:50:51 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

If more researchers published openly, new institutions and norms for judging work would emerge from the bottom up.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk as a Hayekian believer in emergent order, I think if more people felt the way you did, other institutions, norms, and other things would emerge that--from the bottom up Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 13 Feb 2023 · 1:01:25 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    as a Hayekian believer in emergent order, I think if more people felt the way you did, other institutions, norms, and other things would emerge that--from the bottom up

    Said 1:01:25 into the audio

    ↗Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    13 Feb 2023 · audio · 1h 02m · spoken · official transcript

The warrior myth is seductive, and its most dangerous form is the great man as saviour

Our label. 5 claims in Russ Roberts's own words.

The West glamorises the warrior, with a heroic ethos, far more than it glamorises soldiers.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk I do think it's interesting to how much we glamorize the warrior. We don't glamorize soldiers so much in the West, but the warrior has a certain heroic ethos. Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 30 Aug 2021 · 0:50:49 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    I do think it's interesting to how much we glamorize the warrior. We don't glamorize soldiers so much in the West, but the warrior has a certain heroic ethos.

    Said 0:50:49 into the audio

    ↗Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    30 Aug 2021 · audio · 1h 12m · spoken · official transcript

Killing should never be glorified, but it is natural to glorify those who step forward in the face of danger.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk I don't think we should ever glorify killing. But it's natural to glorify people who are adept and in the face of danger step forward. And I think that's part of what that warrior cultural icon-ness is about. Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 30 Aug 2021 · 0:55:13 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    I don't think we should ever glorify killing. But it's natural to glorify people who are adept and in the face of danger step forward. And I think that's part of what that warrior cultural icon-ness is about.

    Said 0:55:13 into the audio

    ↗Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    30 Aug 2021 · audio · 1h 12m · spoken · official transcript

Beyond wanting to be special, part of human nature wants to be subservient to a very strong person.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk I think it's worse than you're saying actually, because you say everyone wants to be special. I think there's also a part of us that wants to be subservient to a very strong person. Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 30 Aug 2021 · 0:55:13 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    I think it's worse than you're saying actually, because you say everyone wants to be special. I think there's also a part of us that wants to be subservient to a very strong person.

    Said 0:55:13 into the audio

    ↗Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    30 Aug 2021 · audio · 1h 12m · spoken · official transcript

The most dangerous form of the warrior myth is believing that a 'great man' will be your saviour.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk That's the most dangerous form, the willingness to believe in that myth that this, quote, "great man,"--and it's almost always a man--is going to be your savior. Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 30 Aug 2021 · 0:55:13 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    That's the most dangerous form, the willingness to believe in that myth that this, quote, "great man,"--and it's almost always a man--is going to be your savior.

    Said 0:55:13 into the audio

    ↗Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    30 Aug 2021 · audio · 1h 12m · spoken · official transcript

Professional football carries a similar warrior myth, celebrating standout players who play on through injury and age.

  1. Russ Roberts Economist; hosts EconTalk Less death, but a similar idea of the lone--even though they work as a team, we focus on the more distinctive players who play injured, who in the face of age and damage to their body still persist and play on and succeed. Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org · 30 Aug 2021 · 0:55:13 into the audioAll korrents from this episode
    Less death, but a similar idea of the lone--even though they work as a team, we focus on the more distinctive players who play injured, who in the face of age and damage to their body still persist and play on and succeed.

    Said 0:55:13 into the audio

    ↗Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)econtalk.org

    30 Aug 2021 · audio · 1h 12m · spoken · official transcript