korrents

korrents · audio

Bret Devereaux on Ancient Greece and Rome (EconTalk)

Bret Devereaux, Russ Roberts · 1h 12m · econtalk.org ↗

35 korrents from this recording

1h
Bret Devereaux, Russ Roberts did not write this page.

Every claim below is a statement made in this recording, quoted word for word and linked to the second it was said, so you can hear it rather than take our word for it. The wording comes from the transcript published alongside the recording; the sentence above each quote is our reading of the claim, not their wording.

  1. 0:00:37 · Bret Devereaux

    there is still very much a popular sense, and I think there is quite a bit of justification for this, that Rome and Greece in particular serve as the foundation for the sort of society we have now.
  2. 0:00:37 · Bret Devereaux

    There is a degree to which I think the contributions of other societies, particularly in the Near East and Egypt, are somewhat undervalued in that story of how we get to the society we have now.
  3. 0:00:37 · Bret Devereaux

    the people who begin as its victims, end as its defenders. Which suggests to me that the Romans were doing something right, intentionally or not.
  4. 0:00:37 · Bret Devereaux

    The Romans were in it for the money. They had no grand dreams of bringing together a humankind. The Romans weren't there to spread Roman civilization or citizenship.
  5. 6 min later
  6. 0:06:59 · Bret Devereaux

    for the most part, revolts against Roman rule are rare because Roman rule doesn't change very much for people on the ground.
  7. 0:06:59 · Bret Devereaux

    Where the Romans tend to get the buy-in is they tend to work through elite culture. And, here, I think the big advantage is that the Greek and Latin literary culture comes to unite elites--the very wealthy, the educated--across society over the whole Mediterranean.
  8. 0:06:59 · Russ Roberts

    When we think about modern empires--you could think about the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the USSR, you think about modern China even, where the ability of a modern state to control enormous swaths of land is somewhat limited.
  9. 5 min later
  10. 0:12:14 · Bret Devereaux

    The popular notion that you will get, is this idea that this is because Greek and Roman literature was somehow suppressed in the Middle Ages, that, 'Oh, the Church wanted to get rid of it.' This is not the case. The Church was actually part of what was preserving it
  11. 0:12:14 · Bret Devereaux

    Literary sources can be deceptive. They can lie to you. They can have their own agendas. But, archeology can give you pretty firm data
  12. 14 min later
  13. 0:26:42 · Bret Devereaux

    I think that this has come to influence the way that the public imagines Rome and what we think about when we think of the Romans, to the point that the occasionally-accurate depiction of the Romans strikes people as wrong.
  14. 0:26:42 · Bret Devereaux

    But there were Romans from all over the Mediterranean world, in all sorts of complexions. Even within Rome and Italy, as a side note.
  15. 6 min later
  16. 0:32:43 · Bret Devereaux

    But, that's simply not, historically speaking, what happened. Rome was a multi-ethnic state at its outset.
  17. 0:32:43 · Bret Devereaux

    I don't think it's an accident that the political entity that ended up being the best at mobilizing resources from diverse populations in the ancient Mediterranean was itself a diverse city.
  18. 0:32:43 · Bret Devereaux

    The process of becoming part of the Roman Empire was incredibly traumatic and brutal. Even in the ancient world, which was a pretty dog-eat-dog place, the Romans had a reputation for being nasty.
  19. 10 min later
  20. 0:42:25 · Bret Devereaux

    Fundamentally, for a warrior, a warrior can't leave society or cannot leave the war behind. It is core to his identity and he can't let it go. That, in a free society is a dangerous thing.
  21. 0:42:25 · Bret Devereaux

    And, I think actually in the United States, I think you see an uncomfortable drift in that direction. We have now broken the taboo against having former or active military officers as Secretary of Defense twice in four years.
  22. 0:42:25 · Bret Devereaux

    soldiers are subordinated to the needs of the community in a way that warriors subordinate the community to their needs. Soldiers are servants; warriors, masters.
  23. 0:42:25 · Russ Roberts

    I do tend to think of war as having some incredible parallels across time and place--being a soldier in war or being a warrior.
  24. 0:42:25 · Russ Roberts

    Because: a warrior, it's like a hipster word in modern usage. It means, like, a really good soldier.
  25. 8 min later
  26. 0:50:49 · Bret Devereaux

    And we rewrite that story. We want that happy ending. There is no happy ending for Odysseus.
  27. 0:50:49 · Russ Roberts

    I do think it's interesting to how much we glamorize the warrior. We don't glamorize soldiers so much in the West, but the warrior has a certain heroic ethos.
  28. 4 min later
  29. 0:55:13 · Bret Devereaux

    Because if you're looking for someone to, you know, stand on the wall, that's not going to be a warrior. That's terribly boring. It's going to be a soldier.
  30. 0:55:13 · Bret Devereaux

    What I find troubling about a lot of the sort of cult of the warrior is that it channels that desire to be special towards this model of military masculinity. Which one, I know is dangerous for a free society. Two, frankly, if you so much as scratch the paint on it, it's also Fascist.
  31. 0:55:13 · Russ Roberts

    I don't think we should ever glorify killing. But it's natural to glorify people who are adept and in the face of danger step forward. And I think that's part of what that warrior cultural icon-ness is about.
  32. 0:55:13 · Russ Roberts

    Less death, but a similar idea of the lone--even though they work as a team, we focus on the more distinctive players who play injured, who in the face of age and damage to their body still persist and play on and succeed.
  33. 0:55:13 · Russ Roberts

    I think it's worse than you're saying actually, because you say everyone wants to be special. I think there's also a part of us that wants to be subservient to a very strong person.
  34. 0:55:13 · Russ Roberts

    That's the most dangerous form, the willingness to believe in that myth that this, quote, "great man,"--and it's almost always a man--is going to be your savior.
  35. 6 min later
  36. 1:00:46 · Bret Devereaux

    The Spartans did not drill for battle. They did not train with their weapons any more than the rest of Greece.
  37. 1:00:46 · Bret Devereaux

    It enforces uniformity and conformity. It is more akin to a reeducation camp than it is to a school, or a training program.
  38. 1:00:46 · Bret Devereaux

    If you inventory all of Sparta's battles, you'd find that they win about half them. A little less than half. Sparta bats about a 500. They're about average.
  39. 1:00:46 · Russ Roberts

    It's the same reason, I think, we root for the underdog, but occasionally we root for the overdog. We want that winning streak to persist. We like the idea of excellence and triumph and victory.
  40. 8 min later
  41. 1:08:41 · Bret Devereaux

    Sparta becomes the go-to comparison point for Athenian oligarchs to complain about the democracy. Much the same way, by the by, modern autocracies are the sort of go-to point for American technocrats to complain about the democracy.
  42. 1:08:41 · Bret Devereaux

    Spartans were uniformly arrogant and violent. It was a product of the training that they underwent, this rearing system. It made them awful diplomats and relatively uncreative strategists.
  43. 3 min later
  44. 1:11:14 · Bret Devereaux

    The first of course, is that we use the past as a model for future action. We use our thinking about the past as a way to think about what to do in the now.
  45. 1:11:14 · Russ Roberts

    So, I care about things like this--I think I'm a little bit unusual maybe--but the truth seems good. I like the truth.