korrents

← People and their mental models

Bret Devereaux's mental models

4 claims Bret Devereaux made fit 4 mental models. Most often: Bottlenecks, Margin of safety, S-curves and diminishing returns. Everything they said here.

Models we see in what they say

Our reading: their claim applies the idea without naming it. The claim is theirs; filing it here is ours.

Bottlenecks

A system moves only as fast as its narrowest point; speed up anything else and nothing changes.

Used by 88 others

The binding constraint on pre-modern campaigning was feeding the army every day it was in the field, not winning the battle at the end of it.

  1. Bret Devereaux Ancient and military historian specialising in the economy… In order to move this army or sustain it in place it is thus necessary to ensure a massive and relatively continuous supply of food to the army. Failure to do that will result in the army falling apart long before it comes anywhere close to the enemy. Collections: Logistics, How Did They Do It, Part I: The Problemacoup.blog · 15 Jul 2022All korrents from this piece
    In order to move this army or sustain it in place it is thus necessary to ensure a massive and relatively continuous supply of food to the army. Failure to do that will result in the army falling apart long before it comes anywhere close to the enemy.

Margin of safety

Leave room for being wrong, because sometimes you will be.

Used by 25 others

Pre-modern subsistence farmers were minimising the risk of starvation rather than maximising output, and their apparently backward practices are rational once that is understood.

  1. Bret Devereaux Ancient and military historian specialising in the economy… These small subsistence farmers generally seek to minimize risk, rather than maximize profits. After all, improving yields by 5% doesn’t mean much if everyone starves to death in the third year because of a tail-risk that wasn’t mitigated. Collections: Bread, How Did They Make It? Part I: Farmers!acoup.blog · 24 Jul 2020All korrents from this piece
    These small subsistence farmers generally seek to minimize risk, rather than maximize profits. After all, improving yields by 5% doesn’t mean much if everyone starves to death in the third year because of a tail-risk that wasn’t mitigated.

S-curves and diminishing returns

Most growth slows as it matures; the question is whether the curve is flattening or something new is restocking it.

Used by 22 others

An economy running on muscle power has a hard and low ceiling on total production, because its only real input is land and the returns to more of it fall away fast.

  1. Bret Devereaux Ancient and military historian specialising in the economy… New land can be brought under cultivation (or cultivated more intensively) of course, but marginal gains decrease rapidly (because the best land is cultivated first and because adding more labor to already cultivated land, while it can increase harvests, is less efficient than cultivating new land) and there is a fairly hard ceiling on total production of this sort that was, for the most part, fairly low. Collections: Why No Roman Industrial Revolution?acoup.blog · 26 Aug 2022All korrents from this piece
    New land can be brought under cultivation (or cultivated more intensively) of course, but marginal gains decrease rapidly (because the best land is cultivated first and because adding more labor to already cultivated land, while it can increase harvests, is less efficient than cultivating new land) and there is a fairly hard ceiling on total production of this sort that was, for the most part, fairly low.

The map is not the territory

Every model, word or plan is a simplified map of reality; useful when its structure matches, misleading when mistaken for the thing itself.

Used by 55 others

Long-run GDP charts hide what matters: technologies are contingent and path dependent, so the same number can describe economies that work in entirely different ways.

  1. Bret Devereaux Ancient and military historian specialising in the economy… All of which is why simple graphs of things like ‘global historical GDP’ can be a bit deceptive: there’s a lot of particularity beneath the basic statistics of production because technologies are contingent and path dependent. Collections: Why No Roman Industrial Revolution?acoup.blog · 26 Aug 2022All korrents from this piece
    All of which is why simple graphs of things like ‘global historical GDP’ can be a bit deceptive: there’s a lot of particularity beneath the basic statistics of production because technologies are contingent and path dependent.