korrents

Our readingWhat is a korrent?

Machines are not conscious

Drawn from what François Chollet, Noah Smith and 2 others said

What this subject means

consciousness What it is for there to be something it is like to be a system, and whether that can be measured.

Can a machine be conscious?under our view: A machine lacks what consciousness is made of: life, a body, an inner loop that binds it in time

What they actually said

  1. François Chollet Creator of the Keras deep-learning library and the ARC-AGI benchmark Likewise a static input-output program that has *none* of the properties we associate with conscious beings (e.g. information integration, interoception, temporal binding, embodiment, etc.) has no more reason to be presumed conscious than a rock has to be presumed alive. @fchollet on Xx.com · 4 Oct 2026
    Likewise a static input-output program that has *none* of the properties we associate with conscious beings (e.g. information integration, interoception, temporal binding, embodiment, etc.) has no more reason to be presumed conscious than a rock has to be presumed alive.
  2. Noah Smith Economics writer; author of the Noahpinion newsletter However, this is the most convincing argument against machine consciousness that I have ever come across. @Noahpinion on Xx.com · 3 Oct 2026
    However, this is the most convincing argument against machine consciousness that I have ever come across.
  3. Gergely Orosz Writes The Pragmatic Engineer An LLM is as conscious as my screwdriver, lawn mower or smartphone is - all tools we build to do X or Y. @GergelyOrosz on Xx.com · 3 Oct 2026
    An LLM is as conscious as my screwdriver, lawn mower or smartphone is - all tools we build to do X or Y.
  4. Anil Seth Professor of Cognitive and Computational Neuroscience… My credence in consciousness for current LLMs being very close to zero @anilkseth on Xx.com · 2 Oct 2026
    My credence in consciousness for current LLMs being very close to zero

Added to korrents 3 Oct 2026 · How quotes work · Something wrong? Tell us

Holders over time
01234 Oct 2026 Nov 2026

Do you hold this korrent?Do you also believe this?

I hold this too

Related korrents

Shared subject first, then similar wording. They may agree or disagree.

See this claim on the map