Carol Gilligan, Terry Real did not write this page.
Every claim below is a statement made in this
recording, quoted word for word and linked to the second it was said, so
you can hear it rather than take our word for it. The wording comes from
the transcript published alongside the recording; the sentence above each
quote is our reading of the claim, not their wording.
Their wordsIf you don't say what you really feel and think, if you don't say what you know firsthand on the basis of experience, but you learn what other people want you to say, want you to know, then you will be loved, you will be promoted.
Their wordswhat I had been taught to think of as development, the move towards separation, achievement, success, was in fact more accurately an initiation into a culture that split human qualities into masculine and feminine.
Their wordsIn other words, there was an injunction that was to keep girls from knowing what they knew firsthand on the basis of their experience. And that was the initiation of girls into secondary education and into patriarchy, basically.
Their wordsGirls do quite well up until then. Whereas boys, it's between 4 and 7 that you start getting the attention disorders, the learning problems, the speech problems, the out-of-control and out-of-touch behavior.
Their wordsThe emotionally open voice of the boy will get called babyish or girly or gay. and the outspoken, honest voice of the 11-year-old girl, which gets called rude or stupid or crazy or whatever
Their wordsAnd the under-voice is the voice of resistance. The under-voice is the healthy voice that came before patriarchy landed on you and traumatized you.
Their wordsthe way through the impasse was for the man, the seemingly emotionally clueless man, to get in touch with his emotional intelligence, his 4-year-old, 5-year-old boy, and for the woman to remember her honest, outspoken 11-year-old self.
Their wordsAnd if you ever read novels written by women about growing up, they don't start, most of them, like David Copperfield or Portrait of the Artist with a— some birth of a child. They start with a girl who's 9 or 10 or 11.
Their wordsThe essential relationship between masculine and feminine is contempt. Take that in. This is called Western civilization. What it means to be a man is to not be a woman.
Their wordsAfter 50 years of feminism, the kind of invulnerability that is imposed on boys, whether they want it or not, ensures that by modern standards, they will be seen as a lousy husband.
Their wordswhoever is on the quote-unquote feminine side of the equation has a deep, almost visceral compulsion to protect whoever's on the masculine side of the equation, even while being hurt by them.
Their wordsWhy has psychotherapy, for 50 years plus, done a brilliant job— hundreds, thousands of books— on helping people come up from shame and done a miserable job of helping people come down from grandiosity? Because we don't lean into it.
Their wordsRLT is unique in that we found a way of leaning into the quote-unquote masculine grandiose position and saying, my friend, it's in your interest to give this up.
Their wordsthe minute you say some human beings, whether it's on the basis of race or gender or sexuality or whatever, are superior and others are inferior, you cannot have the superior people have empathy for the inferior people, or they won't be able to maintain their superiority
Their wordsthe so-called inferior people cannot have a voice that people listen to and taken seriously, or they will constantly talk about what it's like to be inferior.
Their wordsSo that these human capacities, which are basic to who we are as human, are in fundamental tension with this social structure of patriarchy. So there's a basic tension between being human beings and perpetuating a patriarchal structure.
Their wordswomen are afraid to confront their husbands because if they do, the man may get angry at them and lash out and attack. The man may get angry at them and walk off and leave or Stonewall.
Their wordsunder patriarchy, all men live lies. The essence of traditional masculinity is the denial of vulnerability. The more vulnerable you are, the less manly you are.
Their wordsmoving men and women into intimacy means Moving the man into real vulnerability and connection and helping the woman move into truthfulness and daring to not upregulate.
Their wordsThe delusion is control, and you can control from the one up, and you can also control from the one down. That's called codependence, enabling.
Their wordsAnybody in the one-down position, in our language of patriarchy, is upregulating whoever's in the one-up position. The person in the one-down, the feminine position, is more empathically attuned to the disowned fragility of the person in the quote-unquote one-up position. than the person in the one-up position is.
Their wordsIt's a great act of courage for the man to open his heart, move into vulnerability, and be a human being. It's a great act of courage for the woman to open her voice and tell the truth about what she sees.
Their wordsAs therapists, we're taught to not confront those kinds of difficult— I'll say men, but grandiose And what we're taught to fear is exactly what traditional women fear.
Their wordsIn our work, we amplify the negative consequences that they're not seeing. Do this or this is going to happen to you. We empower the one-down one to have the courage to stand up and speak.
Their wordsWe say we want the weak to rise and the mighty to melt. And it's directly from you, Carol Gilligan. You cannot love from a one-up. You cannot love from a one-down. Love demands democracy.
Their wordsIf you do change and listen, you're gonna have a happy marriage, you're gonna have a longer life, and probably the biggest, you can spare your children the damage that you went through.