korrents

Gadi Taub

Historian, author and political commentator

1 change of mind on record, 2010–2024

Where they stand

The latest thing they said on each issue, dated. Tap an issue for their words and the source.

Security and territory

  • A Palestinian state Self-rule at most, no state Earlier: Two states, 2010

    Said

    He says he embraced the two-state solution for many years, but it is no solution: it would doom the Zionist project rather than save it.

    “But compelling as it is as a debating strategy, or a form of self-therapy, the two-state solution is, sadly, no solution at all. Rather, it is a big step down the road to another Lebanon. It would doom the Zionist project, not save it, while producing much greater misery and more bloodshed for Israelis and Palestinians alike.”

    Source Gadi Taub, "Sorry, There Is No Two-State Solution", Tablet, 13 February 2024 (Wayback Machine copy)

    How it changed, in full

    Something wrong here? Tell us

  • Settlements and sovereigntyNothing on record yet
  • Gaza after the warNothing on record yet
  • IranNothing on record yet

Democracy and the state

  • Judicial reformNothing on record yet
  • Inquiry into October 7Nothing on record yet
  • Religion and stateNothing on record yet

Society and economy

  • Drafting HaredimNothing on record yet
  • The economyNothing on record yet

1 change of mind on record, 2010–2024

How this works

Each change shows what they said then and what they said later, in their own words, dated, with the source.

Every quote is checked word for word against a saved copy of its source. Translations are labelled.

The short labels on each line are our summaries.

At a glance

Each colour is a position; their order does not mean one is better. A colour runs from a statement to the next one, and each statement is a small mark.

  1. Partition and a Palestinian state For partition 2010Self-rule, Israeli security 2020No two-state solution 2024

Partition and a Palestinian state

Then

For partition

The settlements and continued occupation, not terrorism, are what could destroy the Zionist vision; if the road to partition is blocked, Israel faces apartheid or a non-Jewish state.

“Terrorism is a hazard, but it cannot destroy Herzl’s Zionist vision. More settlements and continued occupation can.”

Source Gadi Taub, "In Israel, Settling for Less", The New York Times, 29 August 2010 (Wayback Machine copy)

10 years, 2 months later

Later

Self-rule, Israeli security

The Palestinians should get some measure of self-rule while Israel keeps security authority in the broad sense; he calls the Trump plan, with sovereignty in the Jordan Valley, a dream.

"נצטרך לתת להם איזו מידה של ניהול עצמי, כשהסמכות הביטחונית בידינו במובן הרחב של המילה"

Our translation We will have to give them some measure of self-management, with the security authority in our hands in the broad sense of the word.

Source השמאלן חזר בשאלה (עפרה לקס, ערוץ 7 / בשבע) (as reported by inn.co.il)

3 years, 3 months later

Latest

No two-state solution

He says he embraced the two-state solution for many years, but it is no solution: it would doom the Zionist project rather than save it.

“But compelling as it is as a debating strategy, or a form of self-therapy, the two-state solution is, sadly, no solution at all. Rather, it is a big step down the road to another Lebanon. It would doom the Zionist project, not save it, while producing much greater misery and more bloodshed for Israelis and Palestinians alike.”

Source Gadi Taub, "Sorry, There Is No Two-State Solution", Tablet, 13 February 2024 (Wayback Machine copy)

Something wrong here? Tell us