korrents

korrents · video

Discussion between Lisa Feldman Barrett and Mark Solms on the nature of emotion (Part 2)

Lisa Feldman Barrett · 1h 36m · youtube.com ↗

27 korrents from this recording

1h
Lisa Feldman Barrett did not write this page.

Every claim below is a statement made in this recording, quoted word for word and linked to the second it was said, so you can hear it rather than take our word for it. The wording comes from the transcript published alongside the recording; the sentence above each quote is our reading of the claim, not their wording.

  1. 0:05:00 · watch on youtube.com↗

    they're not noise, but they also don't have inherent meaning. They're made meaningful by interaction with signals in the brain. That's true for vision. It's true for audition. It's true for somatosensory, for touch.
  2. 9 min later
  3. 0:13:39 · watch on youtube.com↗

    just because I'm saying that "I don't think the evidence supports the idea that there are distinct signals for anger and sadness and fear," that doesn't mean that I think there's no distinction, that people can't tell the difference between being cold and being sleepy.
  4. 2 min later
  5. 0:15:12 · watch on youtube.com↗

    And I just want to really make clear, if somebody came to me and showed me good, robust, consistent empirical evidence, I would change my mind, because I've done that in the past. And that's what scientists do.
  6. 0:15:32 · watch on youtube.com↗

    Because my other point would be, I don't think people can tell the difference between being hungry and being tired, for example.
  7. 11 min later
  8. 0:26:42 · watch on youtube.com↗

    So, you know, I think it's important for everybody to understand that certain criticisms may apply only to certain views within a framework and not every single view.
  9. 12 min later
  10. 0:38:47 · watch on youtube.com↗

    And one of the things that seems to be the case is that the subgenual anterior cingulate is not specific to sadness. It's a major visceral motor regulation center.
  11. 6 min later
  12. 0:44:31 · watch on youtube.com↗

    But let me also say that, I'm not saying that everything is random and that nothing has any meaning. Okay. I never said that. That is a common misconception of what a constructionist view is.
  13. 1 min later
  14. 0:45:38 · watch on youtube.com↗

    the way that the scientific method works, Mark, is that the person who hypothesizes that there is specificity has to show it, they have to show repeatedly evidence for their hypothesis, they have to try to disprove their hypothesis with, you know, experiments that actually put their hypothesis at risk.
  15. 3 min later
  16. 0:48:40 · watch on youtube.com↗

    So it's a mood disorder, by definition, that means it's a disorder of mood, not of emotion.
  17. 2 min later
  18. 0:50:22 · watch on youtube.com↗

    But, I think that there are no innate concepts or categories for anger, sadness, fear, disgust, or gratitude, those kinds of things.
  19. 1 min later
  20. 0:51:39 · watch on youtube.com↗

    I mean, even adults sometimes have to be taught to distinguish between distress and discomfort. It's something you have to learn to do. And in fact, people do learn it, and it actually helps them, you know, become less dependent on opioids, actually.
  21. 2 min later
  22. 0:53:17 · watch on youtube.com↗

    That is empirical evidence that's been around and replicated for 30-40 years, right, that the acoustics of the cry and the movements, the physical movements don't actually include specific cues to the cause of the distress.
  23. 2 min later
  24. 0:55:31 · watch on youtube.com↗

    So, for me, I resist teleological, I try to resist teleological claims wherever I can, because I think they're problematic in science.
  25. 3 min later
  26. 0:58:25 · watch on youtube.com↗

    When you don't have a really good explanation, or when there are multiple reasonable explanations, the best course, I think, is to keep an open mind. And that means to not take a stand. I only take a stand on things when I think there's sufficient evidence to justify that stand.
  27. 2 min later
  28. 1:00:31 · watch on youtube.com↗

    But when there's really an overwhelming amount of evidence that calls your view into doubt, if you consistently maintain your view, despite the evidence, then that isn't doing science, that is the definition of an ideology. Ideas that resist evidence.
  29. 1 min later
  30. 1:01:43 · watch on youtube.com↗

    and came to the conclusion that there is no specificity in that way. There's no universality. And that it's not random, either. People don't move their faces randomly.
  31. 2 min later
  32. 1:03:16 · watch on youtube.com↗

    And I think the basic emotion view is not responsive to evidence. At least the evidence that I'm aware of.
  33. 2 min later
  34. 1:05:42 · watch on youtube.com↗

    And that problem is that sometimes the interpretation of evidence is embedded in the description of the evidence.
  35. 1 min later
  36. 1:07:04 · watch on youtube.com↗

    So a really good scientist would not talk about "fear," they would talk about "freezing behavior," or they would talk about "avoidance," or they would talk about something that's more behavioral.
  37. 1 min later
  38. 1:07:34 · watch on youtube.com↗

    But I would also say that, as a general rule, our field is a little bit sloppy with keeping that distinction clear.
  39. 2 min later
  40. 1:09:24 · watch on youtube.com↗

    what you would see that I said was that "interoceptive network" is a bit of a misnomer, because even though these are the primary areas that are involved in interoception, it's a whole-brain phenomenon.
  41. 3 min later
  42. 1:12:37 · watch on youtube.com↗

    Humans always draw the boundaries. None of these things are natural kinds, because there are multiple boundaries that you could draw.
  43. 3 min later
  44. 1:15:18 · watch on youtube.com↗

    And there are no natural kinds, as far as I can see, in any field, even in chemistry and physics. Even the prototypic natural kind, which would be the elements of the periodic table, don't meet all the criteria for natural kinds, according to philosophers.
  45. 3 min later
  46. 1:17:59 · watch on youtube.com↗

    Whereas I would say, based on the extended evolutionary synthesis, or what's called the evo-devo approach, that context and learning... that context and experience are fully causal along with genes.
  47. 2 min later
  48. 1:20:14 · watch on youtube.com↗

    I think the evidence suggests that there's a primary role, that we have the kind of nature that requires nurture. We have the kind of genes that require input from the environment.
  49. 7 min later
  50. 1:27:14 · watch on youtube.com↗

    A wavelength of light isn't a color, it's a wavelength of light. And for you to experience it as a color, it has to interact with the signals in your brain.
  51. 2 min later
  52. 1:28:56 · watch on youtube.com↗

    If fear is a natural kind, it should be possible to find objective criteria. But there are no objective criteria that anybody has ever been able to show