-
0:01:02 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsAnd I just want to also mention that it's really rare for two scientists to speak to each other in advance of a critique like this. And I would also say, it's very rare for scientists who disagree with each other, to talk to each other at all, sometimes.
- 8 min later
-
0:09:19 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsAnd popular science books, as you know, Mark, are not the same thing as the scientific research that supports those books. What I mean by that is, we use metaphors.
-
0:09:38 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsAnd as you know, all metaphors are wrong. And what we do in science writing is we try to pick the metaphor that's least wrong for our purposes, that does the least violence or that impacts the validity of the statements, the least
- 2 min later
-
0:12:01 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsthat brains evolved, it seems, evolved in concert with the growth of the size and complexity of bodies, and one of their most important jobs is regulating the state of the body, modeling the state of the body and regulating the state of the body.
-
0:12:24 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsAnd the most metabolically efficient way to do that is predictively. So the brain is always regulating the body and coordinating all the systems, and the body is sending signals back to the brain, which the brain uses to confirm or correct its model of the current sensory state of the body.
- 1 min later
-
0:13:04 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsAnd interoception, we're not, we are not particularly wired to have very precise sensations have interoceptive events in the body.
- 2 min later
-
0:14:54 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsSo just like brightness and loudness are properties of consciousness, affect is also a property of consciousness. So feeling, you know, pleasant or unpleasant, comfortable, uncomfortable, worked up or calm.
- 1 min later
-
0:15:36 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsBut I never said, I might have said valence and arousal and left other features of affect unspecified, but I don't think I've ever said that it's only valence and arousal, because the data don't support that view. There are other features of affect, like a feeling of effort.
- 4 min later
-
0:20:03 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsBut there are definable criteria for natural kind categories. And I don't think emotions meet those criteria under any, any, by anybody's research actually.
-
0:20:22 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsbecause actually, the theory of constructed emotion is a constructionist view that certainly has elements of social construction, but it also has elements of psychological construction and neural construction.
- 1 min later
-
0:21:11 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsthe infant's brain is wired, according to... Brains wire themselves to their world, and the world is curated for infants by their caregivers.
- 4 min later
-
0:25:10 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsSo basically, predictions are concepts. They're not, concepts don't trigger predictions. Predictions are concepts, they're groups of concepts. Sorry, concepts are groups of predictions that are similar to each other in some way.
- 9 min later
-
0:33:42 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsyou don't need a word to have a concept, but you do need to have... your brain has to be able to make the concept in order to have the experience.
- 1 min later
-
0:35:01 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsIt's just that words are super useful ways to learn abstract concepts, to learn concepts where the instances might differ in their sensory and motor features.
- 1 min later
-
0:36:02 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsbut even in a two hour old larval zebrafish, those reflexes are not executed in an obligatory punctate way.
- 1 min later
-
0:36:56 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordswhich is why in fear, sometimes you run away, sometimes you freeze, sometimes you fight, sometimes you cry. In Bali, people fall asleep. There's no specific sensory motor pattern for an abstract concept, which is what I think emotions are.
- 7 min later
-
0:44:14 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsSo you are always in a state where an affect is relevant to consciousness. Sometimes it's in the foreground. And sometimes it's in the background, but it's always there, in cognition and in perception.
- 2 min later
-
0:45:57 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsbut I don't think there's one qualia for disgust. For example, there are instances of disgust where people are feeling very pleasant. There are instances where they feel unpleasant. Same thing for fear, there are instances of pleasant fear, there are instances of unpleasant fear.
-
0:46:23 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsSo my point is that it's not that everything is the same, it's that there's variation, I would say, within a category. And there's also similarity across categories. Which means the boundaries aren't firm.
- 12 min later
-
0:57:53 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsI think, for example, affect, valence is innate, probably, I don't think you have to teach an infant, what is pleasant and what is unpleasant. So, but um, I don't think that anger, sadness, fear, and so on constitute categories, distinct categories of affect in the way that you mean them.
- 3 min later
-
1:00:31 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsSo, I don't, based on my understanding of the anatomy, and also on the functional dynamics in the brain, I don't think there you can even make a very strong claim about there being separate interoceptive and exteroceptive processing.
- 4 min later
-
1:04:08 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsSo you can take, what they do is they take a lot of detailed signals and compress them into lower dimensional summaries. That's what I think affect is. It's a compression, it's a lower dimensional representation. Not that one thing is triggering another.
- 6 min later
-
1:10:29 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsthere are many, many, many cases where people feel pain when there is no ascending nociceptive signal. That's chronic pain. And there are also cases where people, there is tissue damage, and, there are nociceptive signals, and people do not feel pain.
- 4 min later
-
1:14:46 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsI don't think there's a one to one correspondence between the qualia as you would say that people experience and the biological signals that are occurring under the hood. And I also think there's evidence, there's really good evidence that, that these qualia are continuous, they're not discrete.
- 14 min later
-
1:29:08 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsYou observe behaviors in animals and you make an inference. It's your subjective inference.
- 1 min later
-
1:30:27 · watch on youtube.com↗
Their wordsBecause nobody has ever discovered chemically, anatomically, anything, precise boundaries in circuitry. They're basically, it's just like in systems theory, you as the scientist decide what's in the system and what's outside the system.