korrents

korrents · piece

Bryan Caplan - Feminists, Billionaires, and Demagogues (Dwarkesh Podcast transcript)

Bryan Caplan · 20 Oct 2022

Read the piece on dwarkesh.com ↗

30 korrents from this piece ↓

Bryan Caplan did not write this page.

Every claim below was made in this piece, quoted word for word and numbered in the order the piece makes them, so you can read it there rather than take our word for it. The sentence above each quote is our reading of the claim, not their wording. Each quote was checked against a stored copy of the page at build time; where the two differ, the quote is the fact.

  1. Just looking at a group and saying, “We need to get more members of Group X,” is the wrong way to approach it. Rather, you need to be focusing on, “Let's try to figure out the best way of getting the top quality people here.”
  2. So besides defending meritocracy on its merits, I would actually also say that the slippery slope argument is not one that should be dismissed lightly. There's a lot of evidence that it does actually fit the facts.
  3. What I say is that the really distinguishing view of feminism is that society treats women less fairly than men.
  4. people have become very hyper-concerned with the mistreatment of women, which means that feminism is becoming less true as a result because when people are really hyper-concerned that they might be unfair to someone, they are even less likely to be unfair to them.
  5. The main one is paternal support for children. In 1940, the odds that you could count on the biological father of your children to help you to raise them was maybe 90%. Now it's probably more like 60%, 70%.
  6. So I would say that there's more harm being done by the sheer distraction of putting so much emphasis upon small, exaggerated, or reverse problems that bother feminists in the first world while ignoring and indirectly causing people to forget or neglect actual serious problems in some other countries.
  7. people generally confuse being radical with being unfriendly. And most of the harm that is done to radical causes is due to the unfriendliness rather than the radicalism.
  8. So unfairness, where there's no human being that does it, seems like a very strange idea to me. Just from the get-go, well, so who was unfair to you? “The universe is unfair.” Then I mean, the correct term there is unfortunate, not unfair.
  9. In the data I know of, the evidence of women earning less money than men while doing the same job is quite low. So there's very little gender disparity in earnings once you make the obvious statistical adjustments for being in the same occupation.
  10. Looking at the evidence, it is totally standard now for male managers to admit that they are reluctant to mentor female employees because they're so worried.
  11. Friendship is more important than any particular issue. This is not only my personal view, it is the advice that I give to everyone listening. Keep your friends, bend over backward in order to keep your friends, and realize that most conflicts are caused by misunderstandings.
  12. The same thing I think is going on in workplaces where there is an ideology saying that we should take the side of the most hypersensitive person. This is not a good approach for human beings to get along with each other.
  13. If there's a subject like math that is male-dominated, the reasonable thing is to say, “Well, if you want to get in on that, you're going to need to go and become simpatico with the mindset of the people that are already there and then push the margin.”
  14. Obviously, the forgiveness really means, “We're going to go and transfer the cost of this debt from the elites that actually ran up the bill to the general population.”
  15. My first pass on this is always that it's an artifact of measurement to the medicalization of society. It's basically just measurement.
  16. Just to realize the numbers are complicated; no obvious story fits. It would be really ideologically convenient for me to say feminism is leading women to kill themselves. But the numbers don't work.
  17. Most of the reason why Haitians are poor is not that there's anything wrong with individual Haitians. Most of the reason is that there's something really wrong with Haiti.
  18. it's totally scalable, and this is just a massive missed opportunity where we really could go and rescue hundreds of millions of people, billions of people, from poverty in a short amount of time.
  19. In terms of more fundamental arguments, I would say that the idea that you can spot talent with a Zoom call and a 1500-word essay is ludicrous.
  20. there is very strong evidence that, for multiple reasons, hardly any employer does the strategy of hire, watch, and then fire if you're disappointing.
  21. Poland increased its population by 10% in a month, and the country looked fine. No one there was complaining, and I could see why.
  22. Poland was doing the best thing where the day you show up, you can get a job there. You're totally legal to work.
  23. You want to do it from a position of strength. You don't wait before the fanatics have the upper hand and there's blood in the streets and then say, Oh gee, what do we do now? You want to jump the gun when things are peaceful.
  24. I’ll bet that there’s a 99% chance that without Lenin, even with all the other Bolsheviks, it wouldn't have happened.
  25. On the other hand, for almost anything involving major wars, I’d say almost all major wars could be avoided by one side giving in.
  26. The norm is not peaceful and prosperous societies throughout human history. The norm is impoverished and war-prone societies.
  27. My pet theory is that if we're not from lobbying from developers, basically zero things would be built in America because building things has almost no demagogic appeal.
  28. Public opinion is much more important for policy than interest groups. Contrary to what Mancer Olson said, if you really look at what interest groups do normally, they're trying to work in the fine print.
  29. I'll stick my neck out for anarcho-capitalism and say that this is really the best system if we can figure out a way of doing it.
  30. it can be extremely socially valuable to go and have seemingly unreasonably large rewards for people that do something useful because it doesn't just incentivize the winner, it incentivizes all the potential winners.

Keep reading

The other pieces are the ones whose claims are worded most like this one's. That measures language, not agreement: they may argue the opposite.