korrents

korrents · piece

Ada Palmer on Viking Metaphysics, Contingent Moments, and Censorship (Conversations with Tyler, Ep. 191)

Ada Palmer · 4 Oct 2023

Read the piece on conversationswithtyler.com ↗

30 korrents from this piece ↓

Ada Palmer did not write this page.

Every claim below was made in this piece, quoted word for word and numbered in the order the piece makes them, so you can read it there rather than take our word for it. The sentence above each quote is our reading of the claim, not their wording. Each quote was checked against a stored copy of the page at build time; where the two differ, the quote is the fact.

  1. I like to describe it as, “The Renaissance is just the Middle Ages, only slightly bigger and more so.” So, all of the same causes of violence and all of the same causes of death that were happening in the Middle Ages were able to happen on a larger scale once we hit 1400.
  2. most sorts of day laborers — which is the bottom of the economic totem pole in the city — earned enough to live on working three days a week and spent the other several days of the week enjoying themselves and looking at art.
  3. one of the reasons Florence seems to have so much more art than everywhere else is that more of it has survived, which is a decision made by the later centuries by valuing Florence in a unique way
  4. Clutter is definitely underrated. I think the problem with “Is history just a kind of clutter” is the just, because what is clutter, if not a record of the human beings who have been in a place and used it and lived it and all of the delightful experiences?
  5. empathy is vital to our ability to work with each other, to forgive the past, to understand how it really was trying to do its best when it set up the world we have, and how our efforts to do our best in setting up the future are in no way ethically superior to the efforts of our predecessors.
  6. Weirdly, right now, I would say that one of the ones that’s most undervalued is biography, unfortunately, partly because biography was a very fashionable genre in the 19th century and very early 20th century, and so as a reaction against it, it’s been pushed away.
  7. So, biography has come to be an almost gendered practice of history, associated with those women who got pushed out of the academy and are trying to support themselves as scholars independently.
  8. We often forget that people who lived through one thing are still alive for the next unless we approach them beginning to end through the art of biography.
  9. Those moments are what remind us that we are also powerful, and that every single one of us shapes history, not just the people whose names are in newspaper headlines.
  10. It’s not mainly that women scholars understand it, but it was the entry of women scholars into the field that helped us understand it.
  11. Diderot’s Jacques le Fatalist reminds us that there’s only one contract between the author and the reader, truly, which is, when you finish each sentence, you will want to read the subsequent sentence.
  12. He’s playing around with the structure of a novel, all of which is a complicated attempt to portray an atheistic cosmos
  13. The adoption of genderless language isn’t, by itself, going to mean that people abandon this ancient vocabulary of performance.
  14. It’s fascinating to look at the redeployment in transformation over time of so sophisticated a cultural construction as gender, and I think both Diderot and I are interested in that, inasmuch as it gets to the edges of what is biology versus what is culture and how 90 percent of it is culture.
  15. It was perfectly natural, in the same way, for clandestine bookshops to generate these works that are pornography and radical philosophy at the same time.
  16. In that way, Sade is using pornography to open the questions that Darwin will later answer.
  17. I think we would’ve received a much more deist version of what ends up being a very Catholic set of ideas about ontology and physics.
  18. Probably, we would’ve therefore seen even more scientific laboratories develop in France in that period, as opposed to the centers of material of experimental science settling in England, Scotland, and Italy.
  19. Whenever a polity is in extremis, it has a bit less of a robust opportunity to raise the intellectuals that are necessary to have a leading position.
  20. But there are certainly two dozen equally innovative and important people from Spain or Italy in the same moment — if not more — who aren’t famous in the anglophone histories of science because we center the nationalistically celebrated British Isles area more
  21. They therefore are actually very sympathetic to the radical ideas that are circulating because they are fresh-out-of-college intelligentsia who are also excited by these new ideas, and they tend to let through a lot of things.
  22. Zooming out, however, the biggest pattern in all of them is that the most common form of censorship is self-censorship. But the majority of self-censorship is intentionally cultivated by an outside power.
  23. But what they want to do is silence Descartes and dozens of others who saw what happened to Galileo, were scared and therefore never wrote the treatises that they otherwise would have.
  24. It’s politically dangerous to censor pornography because censorship is a very blunt instrument, and we must always imagine how a tool we set up to censor something will be used in the future by bad actors we disagree with.
  25. Almost all censorship isn’t carried out by creating a new institution to do it, but by repurposing an old institution that’s already there.
  26. But I would say it is a taboo, and a taboo is a kind of censorship because censorship isn’t exclusively state actors or organized actors. There’s a lot of bottom-up, grassroots censorship as well, and taboos are part of that.
  27. It lets us see what it was like for that world to encounter a different world. It’s sort of like alien first contact, and there it is, preserved live for us in the margins of a book.
  28. I think that it’s not that we need to eliminate the differences between men and women; it’s that we need to get more of those female-coded problem-solving behaviors to be welcome in positions of power in one way or another.
  29. Nobody gets their first glimpse of the Renaissance without already having run into the Renaissance in some form of fiction. We all encounter stories about this stuff before we encounter the scholarship.
  30. we can save democracy by making people actually be confident in democracy. The first step to that is people being confident that what they do actually makes a difference.

Keep reading

The other pieces are the ones whose claims are worded most like this one's. That measures language, not agreement: they may argue the opposite.