Benny Gantz
Former Defence Minister of Israel · Blue and White / National Unity
2 changes of mind on record, 2019–2024
Where they stand
The latest thing they said on each issue, dated. Tap an issue for their words and the source.
Security and territory
A Palestinian state No Palestinian state for now
Said
In a New York Times op-ed he writes that opposition to recognising Palestinian statehood is at the heart of Israel's national security consensus, and that any path to broader Palestinian civil autonomy must first show a long record of accountable governance, de-radicalisation and a crackdown on terror.
“Opposition to the recognition of Palestinian statehood stands at the heart of that consensus. Any path forward for broader Palestinian civil autonomy must first incorporate a proven long-term track record of accountable governance, comprehensive de-radicalization reforms and a successful crackdown on terrorist elements targeting Israelis.”
Source What the World Gets Wrong About Israel (Benny Gantz, The New York Times)
- Settlements and sovereigntyNothing on record yet
Gaza after the war An international body runs Gaza
Said
Welcoming President Trump's plan, he calls for implementing it: returning all the hostages, keeping Israel's security freedom of action, replacing Hamas rule and bringing Arab states into Gaza, as he says he proposed a year and a half earlier.
"צריך לממש את תוכנית הנשיא, להשיב את כל חטופינו, לשמור על חופש פעולה ביטחוני, להחליף את שלטון החמאס ולהכניס את מדינות ערב לעזה כפי שהצעתי כבר לפני שנה וחצי."
Our translation The President's plan must be implemented: return all our hostages, keep security freedom of action, replace Hamas rule and bring the Arab states into Gaza, as I already proposed a year and a half ago.
Source בני גנץ ב-X
Iran Pressure Iran, force as a last resort
Said
He says the emerging agreement with Iran looks like a strategic failure that will require Israel to wage a diplomatic, military and legal struggle in the coming years, and that Israel must not accept limits on its freedom of action in Lebanon.
"ההסכם המסתמן עם איראן נראה ככישלון אסטרטגי שיצריך את ישראל לצאת למאבק מדיני, צבאי ומשפטי בשנים הבאות אותו תוכל להוביל רק ממשלה ציונית רחבה."
Our translation The emerging agreement with Iran looks like a strategic failure that will require Israel to go out to a diplomatic, military and legal struggle in the coming years, which only a broad Zionist government will be able to lead.
Source בני גנץ ב-X
Democracy and the state
Judicial reform Court reform only by agreement Earlier: Defends the courts' powers, 2022
Said
At the Bar Association's conference he says a real judicial reform is needed, for the citizen, not the politicians.
"נדרשת רפורמה משפטית אמיתית, לא למען הפוליטיקאים, אלא למען האזרח"
Our translation A real judicial reform is needed, not for the politicians, but for the citizen
Source גנץ: נדרשת רפורמה משפטית - רק הממשלה הזו תוכל להוביל אותה (כיפה) (as reported by kipa.co.il)
Inquiry into October 7 A state commission of inquiry
Said
He says a report of a warning the prime minister received days before October 7 shows the urgent need for a state commission of inquiry, which he says only a broad Zionist government can establish.
"הפרסום על ההתרעה שקיבל ראש הממשלה כמה ימים לפני טבח השבעה באוקטובר הוא דוגמה נוספת לצורך הדחוף בהקמת ועדת חקירה ממלכתית שתביא לחקר האמת ומניעת אסון נוסף."
Our translation The report on the warning the prime minister received a few days before the October 7 massacre is another example of the urgent need to establish a state commission of inquiry that will get to the truth and prevent another disaster.
Source בני גנץ ב-X
- Religion and stateNothing on record yet
Society and economy
Drafting Haredim Draft Haredim, with sanctions
Said
He frames the election as a choice between a draft law for all and an evasion law, and says only a broad Zionist government can pass it before the next government is formed.
"השאלה בבחירות הקרובות היא איזה חוק יחוקק עוד לפני הקמת הממשלה הבאה. חוק גיוס לכל או חוק השתמטות."
Our translation The question in the coming elections is which law will be legislated even before the next government is formed. A draft law for all or an evasion law.
Source בני גנץ ב-X
- The economyNothing on record yet
Who they would govern with
Sitting with Netanyahu Won't sit with him Earlier: With him, or backing him, 2023
Said
Announcing his party's exit from the emergency government, he says Netanyahu is preventing the move towards what he calls real victory, and calls for elections in the autumn.
"לצערי, נתניהו מונע מאיתנו להתקדם לניצחון האמיתי, שהוא ההצדקה למחיר הכואב והמתמשך. לכן, אנחנו עוזבים היום את ממשלת החירום, בלב כבד, אך בלב שלם."
Our translation Sadly, Netanyahu is preventing us from advancing to the real victory, which is the justification for the painful and ongoing price. Therefore, today we are leaving the emergency government, with a heavy heart but a whole one.
Source גנץ בנאום פרישה דרמטי: "בלב כבד אך שלם, אנחנו עוזבים את הממשלה" (JDN) (as reported by jdn.co.il)
2 changes of mind on record, 2019–2024
How this works
Each change shows what they said then and what they said later, in their own words, dated, with the source.
Every quote is checked word for word against a saved copy of its source. Translations are labelled.
The short labels on each line are our summaries.
At a glance
- Judicial reform Fights the override clauseBacks the President's outlineA real reform is needed Nov 2022Mar 2023Sept 2024
- Sitting in a government with Netanyahu Won’t sit with NetanyahuIn government with NetanyahuLeaves Netanyahu's government Feb 2019May 2020Sept 2022Oct 2023Jun 2024
first said said otherwise
Each colour is a position; their order does not mean one is better. A colour runs from a statement to the next one, and each statement is a small mark.
- Judicial reform Fights the override clause 2022Backs the President's outline 2023A real reform is needed 2024
- Sitting in a government with Netanyahu Won’t sit with Netanyahu 2019In government with Netanyahu 2020Won’t sit with Netanyahu 2022In government with Netanyahu 2023Leaves Netanyahu's government 2024
Judicial reform
Then
Fights the override clause
As Defence Minister, before the new government takes office, he says he will fight the override clause as the way to pass bills that change the state.
"פסקת ההתגברות במתכונתה המדוברת היא פשוט הדרך של הממשלה המסתמנת להעביר הצעות חוק שישנו את פניה של המדינה. יפגעו דרמטית בדמוקרטיה הישראלית ויחלישו מאד את המנגנונים ששומרים עליה."
Our translation The override clause in its proposed form is simply the way for the emerging government to pass bills that will change the face of the country. They will dramatically harm Israeli democracy and greatly weaken the mechanisms that protect it.
Source גנץ בהצהרה לוחמנית נגד פסקת ההתגברות: "נאבק בכל כוחנו" (אייס) (as reported by ice.co.il)
3 months later
Later
Backs the President's outline
After the President's outline is published, he says it is not his dream outline but must serve as a comprehensive compromise or as a halt and dialogue.
"מתווה הנשיא אינו מתווה החלומות שלי, אבל חייב לשמש או כפשרה כוללת או לעצירה ודיאלוג"
Our translation The President's outline is not my dream outline, but it must serve either as a comprehensive compromise or as a halt and dialogue
Source ראשי האופוזיציה קיבלו את מתווה הנשיא: "לא מושלם - אבל פשרה הוגנת" (מעריב) (as reported by maariv.co.il)
1 year, 5 months later
Latest
A real reform is needed
At the Bar Association's conference he says a real judicial reform is needed, for the citizen, not the politicians.
"נדרשת רפורמה משפטית אמיתית, לא למען הפוליטיקאים, אלא למען האזרח"
Our translation A real judicial reform is needed, not for the politicians, but for the citizen
Source גנץ: נדרשת רפורמה משפטית - רק הממשלה הזו תוכל להוביל אותה (כיפה) (as reported by kipa.co.il)
Context: The coalition's judicial overhaul was announced in January 2023; the President's outline was published on 15 March 2023. Gantz left the war cabinet in June 2024.
Sitting in a government with Netanyahu
Then
Won’t sit with Netanyahu
After the Attorney General's decision to indict Netanyahu, he will not sit with Netanyahu in a government.
"בנסיבות שנוצרו לא אשב עם נתניהו בממשלה"
Our translation Under the circumstances that have been created, I will not sit with Netanyahu in the government
Source גנץ מודיע רשמית: "לא אשב בממשלה נתניהו" (סרוגים) (as reported by srugim.co.il)
1 year, 2 months later
Later
In government with Netanyahu
He and Netanyahu have together decided to form a unity government and take national responsibility.
"אני, ראש הממשלה נתניהו ו-71 מנהיגי ציבור נוספים הגענו להכרעה הקשה ולקחנו אחריות לאומית."
Our translation I, Prime Minister Netanyahu and 71 other public leaders reached the difficult decision and took national responsibility.
2 years, 4 months later
Later
Won’t sit with Netanyahu
There is no possibility for him to sit with Netanyahu again; it will not happen.
"אני אומר לכם שנתניהו פגע באורח אנוש בממלכתיות הישראלית ולכן אין אפשרות מבחינתי לשבת עם נתניהו ואין אפשרות ממלכתית או פוליטית. זה לא יקרה."
Our translation I am telling you that Netanyahu has gravely harmed Israeli statesmanship, and therefore there is no possibility, as far as I am concerned, of sitting with Netanyahu, and no statesmanlike or political possibility. It will not happen.
Source גנץ: "אם תהיה ממשלת נתניהו 61, תקראו לי לראיון סיכום של המדינה" (מעריב) (as reported by maariv.co.il)
1 year later
Later
In government with Netanyahu
He stands with Netanyahu in an emergency government, calling it a partnership of shared fate rather than a political one.
"העמידה שלנו כאן, שכם אל שכם, היא מסר ברור לאויבינו, וחשוב מכך, מסר לכל אזרחי ישראל - כולנו יחד, כולנו מתגייסים. השותפות שלנו היא לא פוליטית, היא שותפות גורל."
Official translation Our standing here, shoulder to shoulder, is a clear message to our enemies, and more importantly, a message to all citizens of Israel – we are all together, we are all mobilizing. Ours is not a political partnership but a shared fate.
Source הודעה משותפת לראש הממשלה נתניהו, שר הביטחון גלנט ויו״ר המחנה הממלכתי גנץ
7 months later
Latest
Leaves Netanyahu's government
Announcing his party's exit from the emergency government, he says Netanyahu is preventing the move towards what he calls real victory, and calls for elections in the autumn.
"לצערי, נתניהו מונע מאיתנו להתקדם לניצחון האמיתי, שהוא ההצדקה למחיר הכואב והמתמשך. לכן, אנחנו עוזבים היום את ממשלת החירום, בלב כבד, אך בלב שלם."
Our translation Sadly, Netanyahu is preventing us from advancing to the real victory, which is the justification for the painful and ongoing price. Therefore, today we are leaving the emergency government, with a heavy heart but a whole one.
Source גנץ בנאום פרישה דרמטי: "בלב כבד אך שלם, אנחנו עוזבים את הממשלה" (JDN) (as reported by jdn.co.il)
Context: The Attorney General announced his decision to indict Netanyahu, subject to a hearing, on 28 February 2019; the indictment was filed in January 2020. After a third election in a year and with the coronavirus pandemic under way, Gantz agreed in April 2020 to a unity government with a rotation of the premiership; that government fell in December 2020. Hamas attacked Israel on 7 October 2023; his party joined an emergency government four days later and left it in June 2024.