Avigdor Liberman
Leader of Yisrael Beiteinu; former Foreign, Defence and Finance Minister · Yisrael Beiteinu
4 changes of mind on record, 2013–2026
Where they stand
The latest thing they said on each issue, dated. Tap an issue for their words and the source.
Security and territory
A Palestinian state Self-rule at most, no state Earlier: Two states, 2014
Said
Thirty years since Oslo have shown that a Palestinian state is a shattered dream that cannot be restored.
"לפני למעלה מ-30 שנה מדינת ישראל חתמה על הסכמי אוסלו. הנסיון שצברנו מאז מוכיח שהקמת מדינה פלסטינית זה ״חלום״ שהתנפץ לרסיסים ולא ניתן לשיחזור ושיקום."
Our translation More than 30 years ago the State of Israel signed the Oslo Accords. The experience we have gained since then proves that establishing a Palestinian state is a 'dream' that has shattered to pieces and cannot be restored or rebuilt.
Settlements and sovereignty Expand settlement, apply sovereignty
Said
In a plan he published for the West Bank and Gaza, he proposes dismantling the Palestinian Authority and applying Israeli sovereignty in Area C, with Israel keeping security responsibility across Judea and Samaria and an Israeli-Jordanian confederation in Areas A and B.
"לפרק את הרשות הפלסטינית ולהחיל ריבונות ישראלית בשטחי C"
Our translation to dismantle the Palestinian Authority and apply Israeli sovereignty in Area C
Source אחרי הביקורת: ליברמן מפרסם תוכנית לעתיד יהודה ושומרון (מעריב) (as reported by maariv.co.il)
- Gaza after the warNothing on record yet
- IranNothing on record yet
Democracy and the state
Judicial reform Defends the courts' powers Earlier: Court reform only by agreement, 2023
Said
As the Netanyahu government's judicial bills advance, he says that in a constitutional crisis he expects all state institutions to obey only the Supreme Court's rulings.
"במידה ונגיע למשבר חוקתי, אני מצפה מכל המוסדות הרשמיים, הממלכתיים והעומדים בראשם, לציית אך ורק לפסיקות של בית המשפט העליון."
Our translation If we reach a constitutional crisis, I expect all the official, state institutions and those who head them to obey only the rulings of the Supreme Court.
Inquiry into October 7 A state commission of inquiry
Said
He writes that October 7 happened on Netanyahu's watch as prime minister and that he will answer for it before the state commission of inquiry that "we will set up very soon".
"טבח 7 באוקטובר קרה במשמרת של נתניהו כראש ממשלה. לכן הוא אחראי, הוא אשם והוא ייתן את הדין בפני ועדת החקירה הממלכתית שנקים בקרוב מאוד!"
Our translation The October 7 massacre happened on Netanyahu's watch as prime minister. So he is responsible, he is to blame, and he will answer before the state commission of inquiry that we will set up very soon!
Religion and state Less religious law in public life
Said
He writes that the next government will run public transport on Shabbat.
"בממשלה הבאה נפעיל תחבורה ציבורית בשבת! חיה ותן לחיות"
Our translation In the next government we will run public transport on Shabbat! Live and let live
Society and economy
Drafting Haredim Draft Haredim, with sanctions
Said
He writes that in the next government anyone who does not enlist will not receive a single shekel from the state.
"בממשלה הבאה - מי שלא מתגייס לא יקבל שקל אחד מהמדינה."
Our translation In the next government, whoever does not enlist will not get a single shekel from the state.
The economy Free market, low taxes
Said
In a post setting out what Israel would look like under him, he says he would shrink the number of government ministries, break up monopolies and increase competition to lower the cost of living and strengthen the economy.
"נפעל לצמצום משרדי ממשלה, פירוק מונופולים והגברת התחרות, במטרה להוריד את יוקר המחיה ולחזק את הכלכלה הישראלית."
Our translation We will work to reduce government ministries, break up monopolies and increase competition, in order to lower the cost of living and strengthen the Israeli economy.
Source אביגדור ליברמן ב-X: "ככה תראה מדינת ישראל במשמרת שלי"
Who they would govern with
Sitting with Netanyahu Won't sit with him Earlier: With him, or backing him, 2018
Said
He says Netanyahu is responsible for the 7 October massacre and that Israel stays in existential danger as long as he serves.
"נתניהו הוא האחראי לטבח! כל עוד הוא יכהן, ישראל תישאר בסכנה קיומית."
Our translation Netanyahu is the one responsible for the massacre! As long as he serves, Israel will remain in existential danger.
Governing with an Arab party No reliance on Arab parties Earlier: An Arab party as a partner, 2022
Said
Ahead of the next election he says he will not sit with Ra'am and will form a Zionist government without Arab parties.
"נקים ממשלה ציונית, בלי מפלגות ערביות"
Our translation We will form a Zionist government, without Arab parties.
Source ליברמן בהצהרה שתכריע את הבחירות הבאות (סרוגים, 'פגוש את העיתונות') (as reported by srugim.co.il)
4 changes of mind on record, 2013–2026
How this works
Each change shows what they said then and what they said later, in their own words, dated, with the source.
Every quote is checked word for word against a saved copy of its source. Translations are labelled.
The short labels on each line are our summaries.
At a glance
- Netanyahu as prime minister Backs Netanyahu in officeNetanyahu must not serve Jan 2013Feb 2018Sept 2026
- Governing with Arab parties The Joint List is the enemyAbbas is a coalition colleagueNo Arab parties in government Sept 2019May 2022Sept 2025
- A Palestinian state Two states, with swapsNo Palestinian state Feb 2014Feb 2024
- The Supreme Court and the Knesset Backs the PM’s court planReform, but not this oneObey only the Supreme Court Apr 2018Jan 2023Mar 2023
first said said otherwise
Each colour is a position; their order does not mean one is better. A colour runs from a statement to the next one, and each statement is a small mark.
- Netanyahu as prime minister Backs Netanyahu in office 2013Netanyahu must not serve 2026
- Governing with Arab parties The Joint List is the enemy 2019Abbas is a coalition colleague 2022No Arab parties in government 2025
- A Palestinian state Two states, with swaps 2014No Palestinian state 2024
- The Supreme Court and the Knesset Backs the PM’s court plan 2018Reform, but not this one 2023Obey only the Supreme Court 2023
Netanyahu as prime minister
Then
Backs Netanyahu in office
After the 2013 election, he says the aim is to secure Netanyahu's continued rule.
"שתי המשימות שלנו הושגו: נבטיח את המשך שלטון המחנה הלאומי ונבטיח את המשך שלטונו של ראש הממשלה נתניהו."
Our translation Our two missions have been achieved: we will ensure the continued rule of the national camp and we will ensure the continued rule of Prime Minister Netanyahu.
5 years later
Later
Backs Netanyahu in office
As defence minister, amid police investigations of Netanyahu, he says a prime minister's term ends only on a final conviction, and recommends calm.
"החוק קובע שכהונת ראש ממשלה תיפסק רק עם הרשעה בפסק דין סופי."
Our translation The law says a prime minister's term ends only with a conviction in a final judgment.
8 years, 7 months later
Latest
Netanyahu must not serve
He says Netanyahu is responsible for the 7 October massacre and that Israel stays in existential danger as long as he serves.
"נתניהו הוא האחראי לטבח! כל עוד הוא יכהן, ישראל תישאר בסכנה קיומית."
Our translation Netanyahu is the one responsible for the massacre! As long as he serves, Israel will remain in existential danger.
Context: Liberman was foreign minister in Netanyahu's governments from 2009, ran a joint list with Likud in 2013, was defence minister 2016-2018, and later sat in the government that replaced Netanyahu in 2021.
Governing with Arab parties
Then
The Joint List is the enemy
On the eve of the 2019 coalition talks he calls the Joint List, then including Ra'am, an enemy and says he will be on the other side of wherever they are.
"לגבי הרשימה המשותפת, הם בפירוש אויב. איפה שהם יהיו - אנחנו נהיה בצד השני"
Our translation As for the Joint List, they are plainly an enemy. Wherever they are, we will be on the other side.
Source ליברמן: "לא ממליצים על אף אחד, הרשימה המשותפת - אויבים" (ynet) (as reported by ynet.co.il)
2 years, 7 months later
Later
Abbas is a coalition colleague
As finance minister in a coalition that includes Ra'am, he praises its leader Mansour Abbas for saying on camera that Israel is a Jewish state.
"לראשונה יש לנו מנהיג שמתייצב מול המצלמות, לא בחדר סגור, אומר שישראל מדינה יהודית ותישאר מדינה יהודית."
Our translation For the first time we have a leader who stands in front of the cameras, not in a closed room, and says that Israel is a Jewish state and will remain a Jewish state.
Source ליברמן: עבאס - המנהיג הערבי הראשון שאומר מול מצלמות שישראל מדינה יהודית (ynet) (as reported by ynet.co.il)
3 years, 4 months later
Latest
No Arab parties in government
Ahead of the next election he says he will not sit with Ra'am and will form a Zionist government without Arab parties.
"נקים ממשלה ציונית, בלי מפלגות ערביות"
Our translation We will form a Zionist government, without Arab parties.
Source ליברמן בהצהרה שתכריע את הבחירות הבאות (סרוגים, 'פגוש את העיתונות') (as reported by srugim.co.il)
Context: Liberman was finance minister in the 2021-2022 Bennett-Lapid government, which relied on Ra'am.
A Palestinian state
Then
Two states, with swaps
He supports Netanyahu's Bar-Ilan speech and a two-states-for-two-peoples settlement, with land and population swaps.
"אני אמרתי שאני תומך בנאום בר אילן ובהסדר שתי מדינות לשני עמים, רק שהגישה שלי כוללת חילופי שטחים וחילופי אוכלוסיות כדי ליצור שתי מדינות יותר הומוגניות"
Our translation I have said that I support the Bar-Ilan speech and a settlement of two states for two peoples, only my approach includes exchanges of territory and exchanges of populations in order to create two more homogeneous states
Source ליברמן מבהיר: לא השתנתי, הדברים נאמרו בעבר (nrg מעריב) (as reported by makorrishon.co.il)
10 years later
Later
No Palestinian state
Thirty years since Oslo have shown that a Palestinian state is a shattered dream that cannot be restored.
"לפני למעלה מ-30 שנה מדינת ישראל חתמה על הסכמי אוסלו. הנסיון שצברנו מאז מוכיח שהקמת מדינה פלסטינית זה ״חלום״ שהתנפץ לרסיסים ולא ניתן לשיחזור ושיקום."
Our translation More than 30 years ago the State of Israel signed the Oslo Accords. The experience we have gained since then proves that establishing a Palestinian state is a 'dream' that has shattered to pieces and cannot be restored or rebuilt.
Context: The first statement was made on Army Radio while he was foreign minister, during the US-led negotiations of 2013–2014. Hamas attacked Israel on 7 October 2023, four months before the second.
The Supreme Court and the Knesset
Then
Backs the PM’s court plan
As defence minister, he backs the Prime Minister's plan to change the relationship between the Supreme Court and the Knesset.
"מגבה את ראש הממשלה בתכניתו לערוך שינוי ביחסים בין בית המשפט העליון והכנסת."
Our translation I back the Prime Minister in his plan to make a change in the relations between the Supreme Court and the Knesset.
4 years, 9 months later
Later
Reform, but not this one
In opposition, he says his party supports changes in the justice system but not the Netanyahu–Levin plan, and favours a constitution, a constitutional court and an override by 70 MKs.
"מאז הקמתה, ישראל ביתנו, דוגלת בקבלת חוקה, בהקמת בית משפט לחוקה ובפסקת התגברות ברוב של 70 חברי כנסת."
Our translation Since its founding, Yisrael Beytenu has advocated adopting a constitution, setting up a constitutional court and an override clause by a majority of 70 Knesset members.
1 month later
Latest
Obey only the Supreme Court
As the Netanyahu government's judicial bills advance, he says that in a constitutional crisis he expects all state institutions to obey only the Supreme Court's rulings.
"במידה ונגיע למשבר חוקתי, אני מצפה מכל המוסדות הרשמיים, הממלכתיים והעומדים בראשם, לציית אך ורק לפסיקות של בית המשפט העליון."
Our translation If we reach a constitutional crisis, I expect all the official, state institutions and those who head them to obey only the rulings of the Supreme Court.
Context: In April 2018 the Netanyahu government, in which Liberman was defence minister, proposed an override of High Court rulings; the 2023 statements answer the Levin judicial plan.